A new research report has called for increased focus to be placed on the future design and organisation of youth GAA competitions.
The paper, 'Shaping the future of juvenile Gaelic Games – evidence to inform a youth games framework' states at the outset that it does not seek to remove competition from juvenile GAA and that proposed modified games would still retain score, challenge and competitive identity.
The recommendations are intended to inform future consideration of youth games policy rather than announce changes to existing competition structures.
The report advocates further consultation, piloting and evaluation of proposed approaches before any wider implementation.
But the document has heralded a call to ensure that competition serves development, participation, belonging, and long-term retention — rather than leaving behind those who need support most.
The paper, written by Dr Michael McKay, Dr Paul Donnelly, Dr Richard Bowles and Dr Peter Horgan, recommends that the GAA should introduce a national, evidence-informed Youth Games Framework for U13–U17 players.
This would combine meaningful game-time guarantees for every player and provide formally embedded modified game formats (primarily 11 v 11 and 9 v 9 on appropriately scaled pitches).
It would also propose to reform grading systems that create close, meaningful competition.
Other recommendations include enhanced coach education in inclusion, adolescent development, and player-centred coaching, better fixture planning with greater regularity and cross-code coordination and structural protections for late developers, on-age players, and players at key transition points.
The report is the latest in a substantial programme of research examining youth participation, coaching and player development across Gaelic games.
It builds on the Gaelic Games Youth Participation Study and subsequent research into coaching, coach education and the organisation of youth games.
The latest research extends this work by examining how the design of games and competition structures can support participation, development, and long-term retention.
"This report examines the case for modified games for players aged 13–17. The term modified games is used deliberately," writes Shane Flanagan, GAA Director of Coaching and Games Development in the document.
"It refers to structured versions of Gaelic games in which player numbers, pitch dimensions, goal sizes, rules, substitution systems, playing time and competition formats are adjusted to better align with the age, size, maturation, ability and developmental needs of young players.
"The purpose is not to dilute Gaelic games or remove competition. Rather, it is to ensure that competition remains meaningful while also supporting skill development, decision-making, enjoyment, belonging, confidence and long-term participation."
Issues leading to the undertaking of the research included findings such as pervasive win-at-all-costs ethos which was seen as a very significant barrier to participation among 13-to-17-year-olds.
The paper reports that this culture was rooted in adult expectations and coaching traditions and was seen as fundamentally misaligned with the developmental needs of young players.
Insufficient and unequal access to meaningful game time were identified as some of the most salient factors underpinning dropout among young people aged 13–17.
While the research identifies concerns about playing opportunities and the organisation of youth competitions, it also highlights the positive experiences of many young participants.
Among the 603 young players who responded to the public survey, 89.1% reported enjoying Gaelic games, with almost two-thirds indicating that they enjoyed playing a lot.
The report looks at opportunities to build on the existing strengths whilst addressing aspects of the playing environment that could contribute to disengagement.
Stakeholders consistently raised concerns about the developmental suitability of traditional 15-a-side formats on full-sized pitches for younger adolescents, suggesting that these arrangements can favour physically advanced players while disadvantaging smaller or later-maturing individuals.
There was strong support for the creation of transitional structures bridging Go Games and full competition, particularly at ages 11 to 14.
Meanwhile, early streaming, selective team formation, and the marginalisation of late developers were also identified as barriers to player retention.
Based on these findings and subsequent research across a wide variety of stakeholders, the paper calls for more flexible club structures to support multiple teams and reduce amalgamation pressure.
Modified games (7, 9, 11, or 13-a-side) were also found to be more developmentally appropriate, inclusive, and enjoyable, with greater opportunity for meaningful engagement. Benefits extended beyond weaker players to mid-ability groups.
The research also included practical field-testing at the GAA National Games Development Centre in Abbotstown, where different playing formats were examined in U-14 and U-16 football and hurling.
One of the most notable findings was that 11-a-side games played on appropriately scaled pitches generated approximately 28% more recorded game events in football and 29% more in hurling than equivalent games played on full-sized pitches.
These included increased numbers of passing, carrying, contest and shooting events, suggesting that changes to pitch dimensions, alongside player numbers, could create more opportunities for involvement. While the trials were exploratory, involving four games, the findings provide a basis for further testing of modified formats.
"Youth Gaelic games should remain competitive, but not at the expense of participation, development, enjoyment, belonging, and long-term retention," the report adds.
"The evidence gathered in this study is substantial, multi-method, and consistent. The case for reform is clear. What is needed now is the organisational will to implement change systematically, to evaluate it rigorously, and to place the developmental needs of the young person — not the preferences of adults -- at the centre of every decision about how youth Gaelic games are organised."
Included in the main recommendations are the establishment of a National Youth Games Framework with participation, development, enjoyment, and retention as explicit policy outcomes.
Guaranteeing meaningful game time for all players by introducing minimum game-time requirements at U-13–U-15, across all youth competition structures.
This would require clubs to track and report playing-time distribution across their full panel across a season.
The creation of a graduated pathway from Go Games to adult formats was also recommended. This would see a structured transition phase from U-12/U-13 to U-16, with gradual progression in player numbers, pitch size, goal dimensions, rules, and competitive emphasis.
It would also reduce talent academy games programme footprint at under 14/15 to support more space and time for club activity at under 13-15.
Modified games formats such as 7 v 7, 9 v 9, 11 v 11, and 13 v 13 are also proposed in the paper, to be used in leagues, blitzes, festivals, and development competitions alongside (not instead of) traditional championship structures.
The paper suggests a rebalancing of league and championship Structures with Championship-dominated systems intensifying win-at-all-costs behaviours.
It calls for the positioning of leagues as development-focused competitions with strong participation protections, unlimited substitutions, and rolling participation principles with the retention of competitive championship structures, albeit later in the season.
Poor grading was also identified as an issue, as was the win-at-all-costs coaching culture.
Large panels of players sitting unused on benches should encourage and facilitate two-game formats for larger clubs (e.g., two 9-a-side or 11-a-side games rather than one 15-a-side game).
Irregular fixtures, long periods without games, and clashes between codes and schools were also identified.
So too were calls for dedicated U18/U19 competition structures to bridge the gap between youth and adult games to prevent dropout.
Watch Cuala (Dublin) v Sarsfields (Kildare) in the Leinster Football Club Championship quarter-finals on Saturday from 4.30pm on RTÉ2 and RTÉ Player
Source: RTÉ News · Damian Lawlor
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira