Red Triangle Workers, Loyalists and Partition A North of Ireland History

Author: Fearghal Mac Bhloscaidh

ISBN-13: 978-1836741879

Publisher: Verso,

Guideline Price: £19.99; 256pp

This is an urgent, passionate history of myriad working-class worlds in Ulster during the revolutionary era. Northern Ireland emerged through pogrom, workplace expulsion and counter-revolution but this book argues that a progressive alternative was possible.

At its heart there is a vibrant documenting of class struggle, much of it previously ignored or underwritten. This really is an immersive history from below, focused on the experiences of “ordinary” people, during a period that Mac Bhloscaidh asserts held out the “tantalising hope of an anti-sectarian and democratic future”.

There is a very welcome focus on female workers, the author acting on Sarah Anne-Buckley’s challenge that historians write “women back into the historical narrative so they might rightly reclaim the spaces they occupied in revolution, politics, and domestic spheres, as fighters, thinkers, confidantes and breadwinners”.

He notes too the importance of craft as well as religion in the divisions between “mill and factory, rougher and dresser, Catholic and Protestant”. But Mac Bhloscaidh argues that sectarian division was not inevitable but fostered by a unionist elite intent on strangling working-class unity at birth.

Chapters based around the author’s native Tyrone illustrate how sectarianism and discrimination worked in practice at local level. The activities of a range of socialist and union organisers, many hitherto relatively little known, are brought to life.

While applauding Mac Bhloscaidh’s verve, I have reservations about some of his assertions. His claim that there were broadly three currents running through Irish history – “an anti-imperialist republicanism, a colonised constitutional nationalism and a colonial loyalism” – simplifies an inevitably more complicated reality.

Few of even the most radical Irish republicans were consistent anti-imperialists. Separatists lauded Boer settler colonialists and ignored (or justified) their suppression of the native majority. Republicans (and socialists) shared many contemporary assumptions about race and anti-Semitism. Republicans generally emphasised their Catholicism and disavowed secularism.

Mac Bhloscaidh shows how elements within the unionist elite were entranced by fascism but many republicans were also sympathetic to Mussolini’s movement, and such views were not just the preserve of reactionary “Catholic public school boys”. That republicans often displayed ignorance about life in what Michael Collins called “an inferior Lancashire” can help us understand the dynamics of partition as well. But this book should be widely read and discussed.

Brian Hanley is assistant professor in the history of Northern Ireland at Trinity College Dublin

Source: The Irish Times · Brian Hanley

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira