Just as a united Ireland has moved back into focus, Minister for Education Hildegarde Naughton has approved a Leaving Certificate history course that teachers say will make it harder for students to understand Northern Ireland.
The existing syllabus requires students to study four topics – two from Irish history and two from Europe and the wider world. The two most popular Irish history topics are The Pursuit of Sovereignty and the Impact of Partition (1912–1949), and Politics and Society in Northern Ireland, 1949-1993. The first allows students to study from the Home Rule crisis to the formal declaration of the Republic in 1949. The second facilitates a deep dive into Northern Ireland from Basil Brooke to the Downing Street Declaration.
Of course, the Northern Ireland module should extend into the 21st century but the new specification’s date parameters are very strange.
Only one of three periods can be studied: 1879–1918, 1919–1966, or 1966–2009. Option 1 ends in 1918, with the rise of Sinn Féin and the 1918 election. Option 2 begins with the First Dáil, but without any context, which the teacher will have to supply. It ends in 1966, in the middle of Terence O’Neill’s time as Northern Ireland’s prime minister. It excludes the formation of the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Movement in 1967 and the outbreak of the Troubles. Under the new specification, no student will ever study from the roots of partition to close to the present day.
For European and world history, the three new periods, of which only one may be chosen, are 1917–1945, 1945–1979 and 1979- 2009. Option 1 focuses on the US entering the first World War and the Bolshevik Revolution. Why on earth would you leave out half of the first World War?
The present syllabus covers six periods from 1815 to 1992 and students must study two. The most popular are Dictatorship and Democracy, 1920-1945, and The United States and the World, 1945-1989. Teachers opt for these modules because students love them. They are curious about fascism and see the resonances today.
The History Teachers’ Association of Ireland (HTAI) has joined the growing chorus of unease about the shape of the revised Leaving Cert and called for the new specification, due to be introduced in August 2027, to be paused to allow targeted structural amendments.
HTAI has always had a good working relationship with the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA) and is eager to support educational reform. Nonetheless, it cannot stand over the new specification for many reasons, including allocating 40 per cent to an additional assessment component (AAC) when AI can produce a project in a minute and a half.
History already had a research study worth 20 per cent, which other subjects envied. Students could research any point in history before the 1990s. Students enthusiastically researched local history and familial or other connections, which are much less susceptible to AI plagiarism. For example, if you had a great-great-uncle who fought in the first World War, you could locate primary sources like diaries and letters and discuss them in depth.
One student contacted a Harvard professor. He was astonished and delighted by an Irish teenager seeking primary sources for anti-Chinese US race riots in the 1870s.
The new AAC has a common brief for ordinary and higher levels. All that glorious choice and pursuit of personal historical interests will be gone.
Ordinary-level students and those with additional educational needs will be seriously disadvantaged. The old syllabus focused on tangible case studies of key personalities and important movements, making history less abstract and more accessible. All of that will be gone, too.
Case studies were firmly embedded in what was being studied; for example, Leni Riefenstahl in the context of dictatorship and democracy. Case studies are being replaced by four mandatory document-based investigations, from medieval and early modern history and the 19th and 20th centuries. These are decoupled from areas which students are studying in depth and are based purely on investigation of primary and secondary sources. There is no detail on how teachers are supposed to teach this.
Sadly, the new course is both fragmented and ideological. The new specification insists on critical social justice analysis and identity-focused approaches. It describes the history classroom as a “safe space” to discuss sensitive topics (gender, ethnicity, race, class, religion, values, politics) and cultivate personal wellbeing. We all favour hearing hidden voices, but sacrificing the big picture and key historical personalities just introduces another form of imbalance. I fear this specification will date rapidly, whereas the now 20-year-old syllabus has aged very well.
Internationally, the existing approach is highly regarded, both the emphasis on the big picture of history at junior cycle and deeper investigations at Leaving Cert.
A 2023 Council of Europe report on history teaching across Europe has a long list of aims represented “very well” or “quite well” in the present Irish curriculums, everything from developing historical thinking competencies to awareness of gender issues and minorities.
In 2018, then education minister Joe McHugh reversed an NCCA decision to make history an optional subject at junior cycle. Similarly decisive action is needed now to protect history as a subject.
Source: The Irish Times · Breda O'Brien
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira