A 30-year-old man has been found not guilty of murder but guilty of the manslaughter of a recovering drug addict in Dublin two years ago by the majority verdict of a Central Criminal Court jury.

The State had alleged that Ryan Brennan was part of a joint enterprise with his half-brother to cause serious injury to another man who was believed to have stolen cannabis and cash, but instead in a case of common design stabbed 63-year-old Anthony 'Josh' Fowler to death.

Ryan Brennan, of Lanesborough Gardens, Finglas, Dublin 11, had pleaded not guilty to murder in a trial that began on 16 October last.

After five days of deliberation, the 12 jurors failed to reach a verdict in the case of his younger half-brother and co-accused Connor Brennan Moran, who admitted killing but denied murdering Mr Fowler.

Nearly three weeks into the five-week trial, 23-year-old Connor Brennan Moran, of Lanesborough Square in Finglas, pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to the manslaughter of Mr Fowler on 26 November 2024, at Dunsink Green, Finglas.

However, the State did not accept his plea.

It was the State's case that Mr Fowler was stabbed by one of the two defendants, who were both acting in a joint enterprise to cause serious harm to the man they suspected of theft.

The jury of six men and six women spent 12 hours and 52 minutes deliberating over five days before bringing in a majority verdict of 10-2 of not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter on the first count against Ryan Brennan.

The forewoman of the jury told Mr Justice Patrick McGrath that they had failed to agree on a verdict on the second count against Connor Brennan Moran and a disagreement was recorded on the issue paper.

Mr Justice McGrath thanked the jury for the care and attention they had given the case. He said it had not been an easy case but that the jurors had clearly taken great care in how they went about their task.

The presiding judge then exempted the panel from jury service for the next ten years.

Before the jurors left the courtroom for the afternoon, Mr Justice McGrath informed them that the consequences of their decision "were for someone else now".

When the jurors left the courtroom Garrett McCormack SC, prosecuting, told the judge that both defendants were in custody and that a further date for mention would be needed in the case of Connor Brennan Moran.

In the case of Ryan Brennan, his counsel Brendan Grehan SC said a probation report might be of assistance. Counsel said the prosecution "will want to consider the bigger picture first" so for the moment he asked the court to direct a probation report for his client and put the matter back to a date in December.

Mr Justice McGrath said it was better if both cases "travelled together for the moment", which the prosecution and defence agreed with.

Both defendants were remanded in custody until 18 December next, when their cases were listed for mention before the Central Criminal Court.

Witnesses recount events before fatal stabbing

During the trial, Kaylee Murray, a second cousin of Ryan Brennan and niece of the deceased, gave evidence that Ryan Brennan told her he was looking for someone who had stolen cannabis from him and was going "to kill him".

Ms Murray told the trial that she did not believe that Ryan Brennan intended to kill anyone, but that he wanted to give the man "a slap". The witness said it never occurred to her that anyone would be killed and when she later heard that her uncle, Anthony 'Josh' Fowler had been stabbed, she was the first to tell Ryan Brennan.

She said she got the impression that Ryan Brennan did not know Josh Fowler was dead until she told him.

Further evidence was given by Stephen Hayden, who was with Mr Fowler on the night he died. The witness told the jurors that both he and Mr Fowler were recovering drug addicts and lived with the deceased's brother, Noel Fowler, in a house on Dunsink Green.

Mr Hayden said he heard "a bit of a ruckus" outside the house on the night of November 26 and when he went downstairs, he saw Mr Fowler in the garden, "staggering backwards" and falling to the ground. He said two men were also in the garden, running around as if they were looking for something before one of them stood over Mr Fowler and said, "That's f**king Josh."

Mr Hayden described to the jurors the moment he told his friend, "please don't die," as he held the deceased on his lap after he had suffered the fatal stab wound in the front garden of the home they shared. The witness attempted to do CPR under instructions from the emergency services until an ambulance arrived.

The witness told the Central Criminal Court trial that when he stood up, his clothes were "saturated in blood" and he wandered around the garden in a daze while paramedics moved Mr Fowler to an ambulance.

The jury also heard from Pamela Murray, who said that she received a phone call from both Connor and Ryan at about 9.30pm that night looking for a lift. She said Ryan told her that the man had taken money and drugs and he wanted to go to a house on Dunsink Green to find him. Ms Murray told him "not to go near" that address, as she knew it to be the home of her uncles Josh and Noel Fowler.

She agreed to give them a lift to a different address and picked them up at Connor Ryan's home. She left them at the Kusadasi takeaway in Finglas at about 9.55pm and went home.

She found out at about 1.45am that her uncle was in hospital with a serious injury. Kaylee called her at 5.30am to tell her their uncle had passed away.

Gardaí gathered CCTV footage showing the movements of the two defendants before and after the stabbing. It was the prosecution case that after the stabbing, the two defendants left the jurisdiction in a taxi that took them to Newry in Co Down.

In his opening speech, Mr McCormack said that Ryan was "screaming and irate" and had spent the day looking for the alleged drug thief.

He said they would hear forensic evidence, including analysis of a jacket which Ryan Brennan was seen wearing on CCTV and which was stained with the deceased's blood.

The State had submitted in its closing speech that a single stab wound had been inflicted into the heart of an elderly man, whom a pathologist found had displayed no offensive or defensive injuries.

Mr McCormack told the jurors that they could act upon the evidence that the two defendants had an "animus" and that there was a knife primed that night.

Whereas lawyers for Ryan Brennan submitted in their closing speech that nothing had been put forward by the prosecution to help them draw the conclusion that Ryan was aware his half-brother had a knife or that his co-accused was going to use it in a plan to kill or cause serious injury to anyone.

Mr Grehan, with Maria Brosnan BL, defending Ryan Brennan, submitted that the State's case of joint enterprise against his client had to prove he was intent on committing murder or inflicting serious harm to Mr Fowler but "had proven nothing of the sort".

Counsel for Connor Brennan Moran, Bernard Condon SC, said in his closing address that the State's case against their client, who admitted killing but denied murdering the recovering drug addict, was "clinging onto threads".

He told the jury that what Ryan Brennan said in his garda interviews about Connor Brennan Moran was not evidence against Connor.

Counsel said Connor was following behind Ryan in all of the CCTV footage presented at trial. "What it does not do is support evidence that Connor was going there with an intention to kill or cause serious injury, what it does is to the contrary".

He submitted that on a review of the evidence, there are four possibilities of where the knife used that night had come from. He said it was either brought to the scene by either of the accused men, or the deceased Mr Fowler, or it was picked up at the scene.

On the evidence before them, Mr Condon told the jurors they can say Connor Brennan Moran used the knife - as that is the basis of his manslaughter plea - but they cannot say how the knife had gotten into his hand.

Mr Condon suggested to the jurors "with all the force" of his advocacy that the case against his client was one of manslaughter and not murder.

Source: RTÉ News

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira