Sir, – The controversy surrounding the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre advertising campaign, and the wider question of whether NGOs should receive State funding, raises an important issue about the relationship between the State and the charity sector.

We should distinguish between failures of governance and legitimate risk-taking. Financial irregularities, poor governance or inadequate accountability cannot be defended. Organisations entrusted with public money must meet high standards.

But taking a responsible risk is different.

The State relies heavily on charities to tackle complex social problems. We ask them to provide services, advocate for change, challenge established thinking and influence attitudes and behaviour.

If we want them to do that, we also need them to be brave enough to innovate and take risks, without fearing that their funding depends on always being safe or agreeing with Government.

The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre campaign was designed to get people thinking about consent. I did not see the original campaign, but the controversy certainly made me think differently about consent, even in something as ordinary as hugging nieces and nephews and considering whether that affection is always welcome. In that respect, it made an impact.

The campaign may not have landed as intended and there may be lessons to learn. But that is not the same as poor governance or misuse of public money.

Charities already operate in a highly regulated environment. Threatening funding or imposing ever greater controls when an organisation takes an unpopular position or a campaign attracts criticism risks replacing innovation with fear. We already know how difficult innovation can become in highly risk-averse public systems.

We should expect charities to be accountable, but we should also want them to be independent, courageous and willing to challenge us. Public funding should not require public silence, and responsible risk-taking should not put an organisation’s future funding at risk.

If charities are to help tackle difficult social problems, we have to give them the confidence to innovate, challenge and, critically, be able to manage the risk that is involved in achieving impact. – Yours, etc,

SHARON FOLEY,

CEO,

Family Carers Ireland,

Tullamore,

Co Offaly.

Israel’s Gaza blockades

Sir – Winter is heaping even more misery upon Palestinians in Gaza because of Israel’s ongoing blockade of essential shelter supplies.

Last week, Gaza’s first winter storm flooded around 70,000 tents in a single day destroying 6,000 shelters, damaging more than 17,000 and forcing more than 600 families to be displaced yet again.

Initial UN estimates indicate that more than 200,000 people may have been affected.

Our local partners are responding, even though they themselves are living in flooded tents and makeshift homes. One colleague described how water came into her tent from all sides, causing it to partially collapse, injuring one of her children.

In central Gaza, three children were killed along with their mother when a sand dune collapsed on their tent after heavy rainfall.

The tents that people are being forced to live in across Gaza were never meant to last as long as they have done. However, replacement tents, tarpaulin, timber and rope have been blocked from entering Gaza because they are viewed as so-called “dual use” items by Israel.

As each tarpaulin sheet frays and each tent weakens and leaks, people’s ability to protect themselves from the bitter elements and to preserve what little belongings they have left is eroded. In these conditions, the cold is a deadly threat, with the weakest most at risk. Last winter, 11 children died from hypothermia in Gaza.

Around 150,000 tents are ready to enter Gaza. The man-made restrictions placed upon the entry of goods and aid into Gaza by Israel are needless, cruel and illegal.

Shelter and winterisation items do not pose a threat; they are key to preserving life and must be let into Gaza as needed, unfettered. – Yours, etc,

ROSAMOND BENNETT,

Chief Executive,

Christian Aid Ireland,

Dublin 2.

Ramping up ramp opposition

Sir, – Anyone driving around Tramore, Co Waterford, or many other parts of the country, could be forgiven for wondering whether vertical deflections, otherwise known as speed ramps, are built to any common standard in Ireland. Some are high, others low; some wide, others narrow.

Some are clearly marked, others barely visible. Some are so abrupt that motorists must almost stop to avoid damaging their suspension, even at 15 or 20 km/h.

The Department of Transport’s traffic management guidelines acknowledge that there are no prescribed minimum or maximum dimensions for speed ramps across Ireland.

While they offer comprehensive recommendations on design, construction, signage and road markings, much is left to individual local authorities. The result is a confusing mix of designs and markings, with little consistency from one town to the next.

The guidelines stress that ramps should be properly constructed, clearly marked and accompanied by adequate warning signs so motorists have time to adjust their speed.

Yet anyone driving regularly on Irish roads will recognise that this is far from consistently achieved.

I would urge the Minister for Transport to review the guidelines and introduce mandatory national standards for the design, dimensions, markings and signage of speed ramps.

A consistent approach would encourage more predictable driver behaviour, reduce unnecessary vehicle damage and ultimately benefit all road users. – Yours, etc,

MICHAEL O’ MEARA,

Fenor,

Co Waterford.

AI and its benefits

Sir, – All credit to your esteemed newspaper for coverage of the role of AI in our lives.

Consultant economists like me get emails regularly proclaiming the benefits of AI and how it would enhance the work we do, particularly in econoic impact and appraisal studies.

While I recognise the potential of AI, it’s important that the ground work for such studies is done properly. There is benefit in the process – analysis is refined, writing is enhanced and learning emboldened. AI can’t compete with that. – Yours, etc,

PAT McCLOUGHAN,

Managing director,

PMCA Economic Consulting,

Drogheda.

Co Louth.

The perils of seawater

Sir, – There is quite rightly much concern in Ballyheigue (“Undrinkable drinking water”, Letters, November 12th) about the lack of drinking water due to sea water having entered the aquifer.

I am not privy to the precise reason for this particular problem but for many years as a councillor on Kerry County Council I spoke and warned of the problems that will inevitably confront residents and councils due to rising sea levels.

Many treatment plants of both water and sewage will inevitably be at risk of being adversely affected. Urgent action may be required at many locations immediately. – Yours, etc,

MICHAEL GLEESON.

Clasheen,

Killarney,

Defending Ireland

Sir, – Stephen Collins excellent article (“The EU is offering cheap money to drag Ireland’s defences into the dangerous new world,” November 13th), highlights once again the continuing failure by Government to provide adequately for defence and security.

Without adequate funding, a full-time standalone defence minister, and an absence of political will, the crisis will continue.

The State remains effectively defenceless, dependent on significant assistance from European partners to provide adequately for defence and security, as witnessed last week during events hosted in Dublin as part of our EU presidency.

We have no ability to effectively police our airspace, due to a lack of suitable jet aircraft, a Naval Service equipped with patrol vessels, with limited defensive or offensive capability, and an Army ill--equipped to deal with modern threats.

As Europe invests in its defence and security, due to changed circumstances, there is little evidence that the Irish Government is taking the threats seriously.

One of the first duty of government is the protection of the State and its citizens. With still no national security strategy, and a continuing lack of investment in defence and security, it’s hard to see how the Government is fulfilling its duty to its citizens. In fact, it appears to be a case of abject failure. – Yours, etc,

CONOR HOGARTY,

Blackrock,

Co Dublin.

Becoming Americanised

Sir, – Since when did we become so Americanised? As a middle-ager I don’t recall in younger years the ubiquitous use of the words “like” and “say”. Every second sentence I hear these days has several explanatory “likes” and “says” in it.

Back in the day “like” was used to express when you enjoyed, say, the taste of ice-cream. The same for telling the time … for example if I was meeting you between seven and eight pm, it would be “a quarter past seven” or “half seven”, or “ten past seven” … but nowadays is “seven ten”, or “seven thirty” etc.

Before you know it we’ll be putting luggage in the “trunk” of the car, or opening the “hood” to fill the windscreen washer. – Yours, etc,

DECLAN STONE,

Glenealy,

Co Wicklow.

Honking homage

Sir, – Frank McNally’s piece on antisocial horn-blowing struck a chord (An Irishman’s Diary, November 12th). Should I ever spot him in a car, I will salute him with a generous blast of the horn – not in anger, but in gratitude to a man who can make even road rage a pleasure to read about. – Yours, etc,

ENDA CULLEN,

Armagh.

A tax on knowledge

Sir, – Any small parcel (including gifts and books) sent to us by post from outside the EU is now being charged €3 import duty, €2 EU handling fee (UHF), and €6.95 by An Post so, for example, a packet of sweets costing €1 sent to an Irish child from Britain for Christmas could cost the receiver €11.95.

Books and journals were always tax-free but two parcels with a scientific journal kindly gifted to me by the Smithsonian Institution in Washington have had these ridiculous charges levied on them. A new “tax on knowledge”? – Yours, etc,

MICHAEL D GUIRY,

Ryan Institute,

University of Galway.

Greyhound racing funding

Sir, – I am delighted to see that the current Government funding to greyhound racing is coming under the spotlight.

It gets around €20 million per year.

Those involved like to call it an industry but from what I can see the gambling industry is the only one that benefits.

It’s high time that we followed the example of most other countries that have banned it or will we be told that it’s classified as a “rural pursuit?”. – Yours, etc,

FERGUS MADDEN,

Goatstown,

Dublin.

Putting a price on kindness

Sir, – Has the convenience of instant online payments come at the expense of something more valuable: the simple act of accepting someone’s generosity?

Think about the everyday gestures that make up our relationships. Buying a friend a coffee, picking up the bill for a meal or doing someone a favour.

These are often small acts of kindness offered without any expectation of repayment.

Yet, increasingly, there seems to be an instinctive urge to ensure that every gesture is financially reciprocated.

This thought occurred recently when visiting home. Having the use of my mother’s car over the weekend, I decided to fill it with diesel as a small thank you. I had absolutely no expectation of being reimbursed.

It was simply a gesture of appreciation. Yet, while sitting on the train after the weekend, I received a notification that money had been transferred to my account. What was intended as a simple act of generosity had become another transaction.

Of course, instant payments are enormously convenient. They make splitting bills, sharing expenses and transferring money easier than ever. However, not every favour creates a debt. Not every kindness requires repayment.

Perhaps we should occasionally resist the temptation to settle the account and simply say thank you. – Yours, etc,

LIAM NAUGHTON,

Stoneybatter,

Dublin 7.

Conversations for friends

Sir, – Laura Kennedy’s article gave me new hope as she heralds the power of a meaningful exchange using just the quiet power of words and an ability to listen (“I made a new friend – a rare enough thing when you’re over 35,” November 11th).

Her little gem celebrates the whole possibility of making new friends through actual old-fashioned face to face conversing.

Her insights reflect a full understanding of the changing face of friendship as we navigate through all the stages of life.

In a world that now expects sufficient written warning in advance of even answering any phone calls, it is heartening to read her young voice urging us to take that chance and open up to that conversation which could be the beginning of a great friendship.

As generations retreat to the isolation of boxrooms to communicate with a lot of white noise on blue screens, maybe Laura’s article is timely to inspire this whole debate.

Certainly, her deliberations on the courage to ask those questions should give us all plenty to talk about. – Yours, etc,

CARMEL LYNCH,

Templeogue,

Dublin 6W.

Source: The Irish Times · Mon Nov 16 2026 - 06:00 • 9 MIN READ

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira