The Labour Party has questioned the “legal basis” for interventions by Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill in the staffing and operation of hospitals.
Cork University Hospital (CUH) has been under intense scrutiny in recent months after its chief executive wrote to the Health Service Executive (HSE) raising concerns about patient safety risks arising from staffing restrictions.
The hospital had hired above its allocated staff count this year, health officials have said, and had been placed under tighter recruitment controls to reduce overspending.
Labour health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock said legislation was passed 22 years ago to give hospital managers and clinicians the “power to decide how our health service should be staffed and operated”.
But she said the Minister seemed to think she knows “more about the running of hospitals than the people on the ground, the very people tasked with running these organisations”.
Sherlock told Carroll MacNeill: “I don’t believe you have the legal basis for your actions and I think you’re straying into very dangerous territory.”
She cited a HSE memo issued in October that stated the HSE would make the business case on recruitment “and you get to make the ultimate call”.
Sherlock was speaking in the Dáil as she introduced her party’s motion calling for “honesty and certainty” in the funding of health services.
She said for more than a decade, successive governments had asked the Dáil to approve a budget they knew would “not pay for the services that are demanded and needed” and every year a supplementary budget was needed.
The health service year after year faces systematic “underfunding and mis-funding”, she said, a position backed up by the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, the Parliamentary Budget Office and others.
But the Minister said the HSE was required to manage services within an approved framework.
It “doesn’t exist in isolation”, but “within the wider public expenditure framework”, while additional conditions were introduced “following persistent overruns”.
A post only comes to the department after it has been prioritised by the HSE and recommended by the chief executive.
“The department then checks the fuller cost that’s been identified and the credible means of maintaining it within the available pay budget,” she said.
Carroll MacNeill said investment in the health system was “extremely substantial”, with an 88 per cent increase in the overall allocation between 2019 and 2027, from €13.7 billion to €29.1 billion.
She defended recruitment levels and said 4,000 staff were recruited in the first nine months of this year.
Labour leader Ivana Bacik insisted there was systematic under-resourcing and “clearly a recruitment freeze in all but name with a million people on waiting lists, nearly 500 on trolleys, and 2,900 nursing and midwifery posts vacant”.
Social Democrats TD Liam Quaide hit out at the Minister and accused her of acting like somebody with a “vendetta against CUH”.
He said it “seems very much like you’re trying to make an example of [CUH chief executive] Jennifer Kearney so no other hospital manager will dare put their head above the parapet”.
Accusing her of “hostile neglect” of the Cork hospital, he said she dared to “blame the very CEO and senior clinicians who have been desperately trying to alert you to the dangers”.
The Minister, however, said the Health Information and Quality Authority, which inspected CUH in recent weeks, had “not identified any red flags”.
Source: The Irish Times · Marie O’Halloran
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira