David Harrington can recall with absolute clarity the moment his life changed forever. It was November 2nd, 1988, at the Queen Elizabeth Hall in London, and Kronos Quartet gave the first public performance of Steve Reich’s Different Trains, a landmark composition that hauntingly evokes the horrors of the Holocaust.
“I don’t think audiences had heard anything quite like that before,” Harrington says as the pioneering string ensemble he founded more than half a century ago prepare to come to Dublin to perform the piece at the National Concert Hall, to mark Reich’s recent 90th birthday.
Different Trains is a milestone in the careers of both Kronos, who won a Grammy for their recording of it, and Reich, a godfather of minimalist music. The composer was born in New York in 1936; in the piece he imagines how, as a Jew, had he been born in Europe he could easily have ended up on a train to a Nazi death camp during the second World War.
“Making the Holocaust a central element in Different Trains for me was something I had hoped could happen, and it finally did happen,” Harrington says of the composition, which Reich wrote for the quartet.
That first performance of Different Trains was a leap into the dark: it required Kronos Quartet to play along to the recorded testimonies of Americans and Europeans from the 1940s, including those of three Holocaust survivors.
The tapings give the work its soul and its sense of slow-building horror. Some of the testimonies are from camp survivors – “1940. On my birthday. The Germans walked in to Holland,” one says.
Other voices recall the banality of life in the United States at the time, when Reich was a child shuttling by train between his divorced parents in Los Angeles and New York.
Yet even in paradise there are shadows: one of the first recordings we hear is of an 80-year-old retired Pullman train porter, Lawrence Davis, an African American whose presence is a reminder that the US has its own unhappy history when it comes to human rights.
“As a kid travelling on the train from Portland to Seattle, I remember hearing voices like the Pullman porter’s voice in the first movement of Different Trains,” Harrington says. “I’m of that vintage that recalls those voices that Steve knew about as well and heard in his youth. There’s a kind of Americanness that speaks to someone like me.”
How did the quartet find playing along to the recorded voices?
“We found that we needed our own engineer to travel with us, who [knew] the piece and could get the kind of sound we wanted. Then what happened very quickly after that is other composers around the world realised, ‘oh, this is possible for string quartet’. It very quickly created this expansion of possibilities in our art form. There is before Different Trains and after Different Trains.”
Kronos Quartet even then had a history of engaging with difficult subject matter, he says.
“Before we played Different Trains we played the world premiere of the only string quartet I am familiar with that was actually written in a concentration camp: the Third String Quartet of Viktor Ullmann. We found the score at the Schoenberg Archive at USC when we were artists-in-residence there in the early 1980s.
“We had been interested in music that could possibly survive and been written under extreme circumstances. Then, all of a sudden, to have Different Trains … It was incredibly wrenching.”
Harrington founded Kronos Quartet in 1973 as a way to articulate his anger about the United States’ involvement in Vietnam: he had heard Black Angels, a dissonant avant-garde composition by George Crumb in which the composer articulated his opposition to the war as a shriek into the void.
Kronos Quartet remain committed to justice and to giving voice to the voiceless. Their most recent album, Glorious Mahalia, is a tribute to the gospel singer and civil-rights activist Mahalia Jackson; Forgive Us For, from 2025, features vocals by the late Palestinian singer Rim Banna and works by the Ukrainian composer Mariana Sadovska.
Kronos Quartet have done their bit in other ways too. When Donald Trump restricted travel to the US from seven largely Muslim states in 2017, Kronos Quartet created the touring concert programme Music for Change: The Banned Countries, featuring work from the places affected by the prohibition.
Even this morning Harrington has been thinking about how he might help a promising young musician secure a place at Harvard University.
“I’ve been asked to write a recommendation for … an amazing composer, pianist, artist, poet from Afghanistan. I have been thinking about just the situation that we have in the United States, and what musicians might be able to do about it. In this case it will be a very, very good thing for American society that [the musician] goes to Harvard.”
This mission is never-ending. Next year Kronos will debut a work that uses the cosmologist Carl Sagan’s Pale Blue Dot speech, his passionate reminder that, in a vast, cold universe – Earth is merely “a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam” – we have only each other, and that more unites us than keeps us apart.
This will be at a concert on January 26th to mark the annual announcement of the time according to the Doomsday Clock, a metaphorical countdown to global apocalypse operated by a non-profit group of atomic scientists.
Harrington hopes the quartet can introduce some light to the darkness, which is why they are performing with Sagan’s Pale Blue Dot speech.
“I was thinking about music that taps into anxiety that’s in the air, but then also another quality music can have is it can kind of absorb that anxiety and reflect something other than that, and give us some sense of things.
“And I just happened to listen, literally 10 minutes ago, to Carl Sagan’s Pale Blue Dot speech. It’s incredible that we’re going to be able to use those words.”
Not all of it has gone down easily. In the 1970s, classical purists reacted with horror to the minimalist work of Reich, Philip Glass and Terry Riley – and to the Kronos Quartet. They were offended, often personally, by the desire to challenge the boundaries of classical music, to do something daring, and to make music that was not always easy to listen to.
“You have to get a callus, you know what I mean, if you’re going to want to do this for your entire life. That’s what’s going to happen. All of us in Kronos have accepted that, and I think our composers have accepted that as well. As part of the nature of reflecting our world back to each other, there are going to be moments when some people are not going to appreciate it.”
He smiles and adds that sometimes people are won around. It’s just that it can take a while. He recalls a recent incident in which a woman approached him after quartet performed Philip Glass’s 1998 score for the Bela Lugosi horror classic Dracula.
“She said: ‘I’ve hated Philip Glass my entire life, and I knew I was going to just hate this.’ And then she said: ‘But I didn’t. I loved it.’”
Kronos Quartet perform Different Trains and other works by Steve Reich at the National Concert Hall, Dublin, on Sunday, November 22nd
Source: The Irish Times · Ed Power
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira