Irish artists and writers have raised concerns over the “industrial extraction” of their work to train artificial intelligence (AI) models.
Although such issues were global, Robbie Kitt, chair of Praxis, the artists’ union of Ireland, urged the Government to have a “local focus” on the issue.
Praxis was among several organisations representing artists and writers that appeared before the Oireachtas AI committee on Tuesday.
Kitt told TDs and Senators that their members have had their work used without consent to generate AI promotional content.
Kitt added that the union was also aware of a “number of incidents” where local authorities and publicly funded organisations used AI-generated material such as photos, posters and videos for promotional purposes.
He believed there should be a national policy mandating public bodies to employ creatives instead of using AI to “replace” their labour.
[ AI and its effects on Ireland’s graduates Opens in new window ]
The committee also heard that AI companies have “trawled” the internet and data-mined the intellectual property of artists, musicians and writers to build and train models, with Kitt describing such extraction as “unprecedented”.
He believed AI companies should be mandated to offer routes to recourse for unlawfully scraped content and provide “adequate compensation mechanisms”, arguing Ireland should “drive innovation” in regulation.
Noel Kelly, chief executive of Visual Artists Ireland, told the committee that generative AI was adding further pressures on visual artists who “already face considerable financial uncertainty”.
While there is legislation dealing with copyright and text and data mining, Kelly said an individual artist does not have a “large legal team to tackle this on their behalf”.
The committee separately heard there has been a “tsunami of books published by AI, and that’s only going to get worse”, according to Conor Kostick of the Irish Writers Union.
He said this was “rapidly undermining what was already a fairly precarious means of existence for the majority of writers”.
In a separate session on Tuesday focusing on AI and work more generally, the committee heard higher productivity achieved by companies through AI tools does not “automatically mean higher wages or better jobs”.
Caroline Frederickson, director of the International Labour Organisation’s (ILO) research department, said employers and workers should be able to “negotiate” how gains through the use of AI are used, including on pay and improved working time.
Frederickson noted that global research showed AI was primarily leading to job transformation rather than elimination.
“[But] there are exceptions to that and certain companies may decide in their case that their adoption of AI can replace workers,” she said, adding the “danger” of job loss was “always there”.
Research published by the ILO in May last year found one in four workers globally were employed in an occupation with some exposure to AI, though just 3.3 per cent of global employment was in the “highest exposure category”.
Clerical occupations remain the most exposed, Frederickson said, while some professional and technical occupations were becoming more exposed as the technology advanced.
Women’s jobs are also more susceptible, with 4.7 per cent of women’s employment falling in the highest exposure category, compared to 2.4 per cent of men’s employment.
Frederickson advised committee members to prioritise research in Ireland, tracking adoption among companies and subsequent outcomes.
Social Democrats TD Sinéad Gibney questioned whether they could rely on private companies and employers to be forthcoming with such information, saying companies “ultimately want to gain from the efficiencies of AI”.
“You do have to talk to people actually doing the work inside to see whether there’s an appropriate reflection of what is being said by corporate spokespeople,” Frederickson said.
Source: The Irish Times · Jack White
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira