Alarm bells will have gone off in Dublin at the proposal from European Council president António Costa for the imposition of a digital sales tax on big multinational companies.

This was part of a revised plan for the next seven-year EU budget starting in 2028, on which talks have been highly contentious. Costa sees the tax as a way of raising money directly for central EU coffers, helping to close a financial hole in the proposed budget.

Ireland will not like the plan for two reasons. One is that it threatens to ignite a new row with US president Donald Trump, who hates the idea of digital sales taxes on US firms.

Costa insists the plan does not specifically target US companies. But as it applies to those with a digital turnover of €750 million worldwide and at least €50 million in Europe, the reality is that many of the big US players will be in the frame.

Ireland is the European headquarters of many of these big companies and thus will be central to any developing row. Briefings from Brussels suggest that Costa has proposed the move now because Trump is weakened after the midterm elections. Whether member states agree remains to be seen. They may not want to give Trump an excuse to tear up the EU/US trade agreement. It is very much in Ireland’s interest for this agreement to hold, given the State’s strong trade and investment links with the US.

The Government will also be concerned that more money for EU coffers from the big digital firms such as Google and Facebook could mean less money for Ireland. At the moment big tech pays tax in Ireland on profits earned around the world. If more is levied via this charge for the central EU budget, there may be less tax to be paid here.

Much will depend on the detail of how the charge – set at a rate of 3 per cent on digital revenues – would work. But the part of the OECD corporate tax plan which would have involved more tax being paid by the digital giants in bigger EU markets was seen as likely to cost Ireland more than €2 billion a year. In the event, this part of the OECD deal collapsed.

Ireland had signed up for it – hoping it would settle global corporate tax rows – but has always opposed plans at an EU level, saying that a global solution was the way forward. Over many years a variety of EU plans have come up, with different versions of centralised tax plans at the expense of countries such as Ireland, but none has won the necessary unanimous approval.

[ António Costa revives EU digital tax proposal in bid to reach agreement on budgetOpens in new window ]

The latest version may not either, and Ireland will hope that other countries will join it in opposing the digital sales tax proposal. The plan will get some support, however. Germany reacted reasonably positively to the Costa plan initially and France has long supported more taxes on big tech. So the coming diplomatic moves will be interesting to watch.

Elsewhere, Costa has not taken any more out of the budget for the Common Agricultural Policy, though the Irish Farmers’ Association points out that spending in this area is set to fall compared with the present budget. EU leaders are due to discuss the new budget plan in Brussels this week. A plan that wins the necessary unanimous support will not be easy to find.

Source: The Irish Times · Cliff Taylor

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira