A Scandinavian urban planning expert famously asked to see the development plans for Galway city. When shown its statutory development plan, he was reported as saying that it was not a plan at all but merely a zoning map.

There is a profound difference between imagining and planning. In terms of national infrastructure and energy policy we are in a crisis.

Kieran O’Brien, an engineer and former managing director of EirGrid, recently posted online an analysis of Ireland’s ongoing failure to implement or meet targets in relation to transforming our society from one dependent on fossil fuel energy to sustainable and renewable energy sources.

This underlines Ireland’s endemic problems in bringing about planned change in our society. As noted in yesterday’s editorial in these pages, the Greater Dublin Drainage project in north Dublin was first proposed in 2005 as vital for Dublin’s planned growth. It took six further years for Fingal County Council to initiate the project. A planning submission to An Bord Pleanála was made in 2018, granted in 2019 and later quashed by the High Court because the Environmental Protection Agency was not consulted. In 2025, An Comisiun Pleanála granted the necessary permission. Yet another High Court action ensued and was subsequently settled. We are now told that this €2 billion plus project should be delivered by the end of 2031 – a quarter century after its necessity was identified.

That saga is, unfortunately, being replicated in relation to Ireland’s energy transformation. The National Economic and Social Council warned last year that “much of Ireland’s policy for transition in the power sector is headed ‘into fog’, where visibility and certainty are low”. The report stressed the urgent need to address identified strategic gaps.

O’Brien’s online presentation focuses was on the gaping holes in Ireland’s implementation of its energy strategy. Moreover, O’Brien effectively foretells a looming economic and social crisis which will befall us if we collectively fail to get our energy act together.

Our national power grid is grossly underdeveloped and behind its projected transformation as things stand.

On any view of Ireland’s energy transformation, we will be dependent on LNG imports for the next 30-40 years. We permitted foolish ideological considerations to cripple Ireland’s capacity to use offshore gas exploration to meet these energy needs. The same ideological confusion obstructed construction of an LNG importation terminal which we badly need. Ireland is now dependent on gas imports routed through the Moffat interconnector and distribution centre in Scotland and, in the future, will likely rely on makeshift LNG importation facilities for fracked American gas. If the Moffat facility were, for whatever reason, put out of action, Ireland’s economy would be plunged into the Stone Age.

O’Brien’s presentation describes a very bleak scene for offshore wind power development. This development is effectively at a halt, with big international energy development companies pulling out of the licensing and planning process.

We had huge planning difficulties with onshore wind power development. So the Government turned its eyes to offshore wind farms. In 2019, the Government announced plans for 3,500 megawatts (MW) of offshore wind energy by 2030. A year later, that target was reset at 5,000MW by 2030. Eighteen months later, we had a dizzying projection of 7,000MW by 2030 (to include 2,000MW to be available for green hydrogen production). A breathless minister spoke of Ireland becoming the Saudi Arabia of offshore wind energy and hydrogen production. This wishful thinking mushroomed to 20,000MW by 2040 and 37,000MW by 2050.

O’Brien points out that the Arklow Banks offshore wind farm has ceased operating and is due to be decommissioned, leaving us with no offshore wind power at present. We have established a Maritime Area Regulatory Authority to oversee the maritime regulatory regime and EirGrid conducts offshore energy auctions. But granting planning permission remains with An Comisiun Pleanála, which had to be tooled up to deal with this specialised area.

Some projects have entered the torturous licensing and planning process, but it is hard to see any of them coming on stream within the next five years. Put simply, all projections for 2030 have turned out to be the worst form of wishful thinking.

Ireland already has by far the highest electricity prices (excluding tax) in the European Union. Meanwhile, we are ploughing ahead with power hungry data centres.

With an economy already dependent on a tiny number of multinational corporate taxpayers, we are uniquely vulnerable to any global downturn or economic crisis.

O’Brien’s presentation needs an urgent response from the Irish political system. It suggests that we are paddling our economic and social canoe towards a virtual Niagara Falls. If he is correct in even half of his analysis, we are heading towards an energy crisis rather than energy transformation.

Targets without plans or implementation are just wishful thinking. We need honesty and realism – not daydreaming our way into economic crisis.

Source: The Irish Times · Michael McDowell

At a glance

Topic
Business
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira