On Wednesday, a row between, on the one hand, management and senior medical staff at Cork University Hospital and, on the other, senior HSE management and the Government, dominated exchanges at both the Oireachtas Health Committee and on the floor of the Dáil.
What is the row about and, as winter and peak flu season approach, what is happening to resolve it?
Southern Editor Paschal Sheehy traces the roots of the dispute and monitors the exchanges between both sides ...
It all started with a letter in August.
Well, it actually started many years before that, but August is as good a place to start as any.
On 17 August, Cork University Hospital Chief Executive Jennifer Kearney - appointed just over a year previously - wrote to the HSE's Integrated Healthcare Area Manager for the South and West, Priscilla Lynch, to make her aware of her "increasing concern" about patient safety risks at the hospital as winter approached.
The subject line was marked URGENT, and referenced "patient safety risk arising from employment approval processes".
Ms Kearney, who came to CUH after working in a number of senior management positions in Britain's NHS, set out her position, stating that delays in filling over 800 pre-approved and funded vacancies were creating an unsustainable position at the hospital.
Her language could not have been clearer.
"I do not believe that the current position is sustainable, nor do I believe it is safe to enter the winter period with the level of staffing uncertainty that currently exists," she said.
She added that she was "increasingly concerned" that the hospital was moving from a position of managing operational pressure, "to one where we are managing avoidable patient safety risk".
Ms Kearney sought several steps to address her concerns. These included a derogation from recruitment restrictions that had been imposed at Cork University Hospital; recognition of specific patient safety and winter resilience risks facing the hospital; the immediate escalation of the CUH workforce position to the HSE executive team; and the immediate approval of a minimum of 172 priority posts.
Ms Kearney wrote that increasingly bureaucratic processes and a prolonged suppression of recruitment had led to 348 whole-time equivalent positions remaining vacant, even though funding for them had already been secured.
"My responsibility as chief executive is not simply to comply with a process," Ms Kearney wrote. "It is to speak clearly when I believe the process is creating a foreseeable risk to patients and staff.
"I would rather raise that concern now, where there is still an opportunity to act, than remain silent and explain afterwards why we did not.
"There is a very real danger that we become focused on whether a post has passed through the correct approval gateway, rather than asking the more fundamental question: is the hospital adequately staffed to provide safe care to patients."
Finally, and pointedly, she wrote: "We should not wait for a patient safety incident to demonstrate that the current position is unsafe."
Writing that letter was not the issue. The issue arose when the letter was passed to RTÉ's Brian O'Connell, and he drew attention to its contents two days later when he published the details on RTÉ Radio 1.
The cat was out of the bag.
Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill responded, insisting there was no evidence of an increase in serious patient safety concerns at CUH.
"I am happy to reassure that we have not seen any such increase, nor have we had communication to the National Patient Safety Office or to HIQA about safety concerns," she told RTÉ's Morning Ireland on Wednesday, 26 August.
She went on to highlight the level of recruitment at CUH and within the HSE South West region generally.
"I do have to say that the South West region generally has hired more people in this year than any other region. In fact, they are over their budget, significantly over their budget.
"I have to compare that to the region beside them in Limerick, where you have a very, very busy hospital with much higher emergency department presentations than in Cork, though I do acknowledge Cork is very, very busy.
"But Limerick is within its budget and has hired and maintained its budget, which is finite this year," she said.
Minister Carroll MacNeill added that Cork has had a "very significant increase in staffing" in the last five to six years of more than 40%, alongside a budget increase of 108%.
"I am sorry to say that the increased activity is only 16% and there is more to do in Cork to get the best value and the best deployment of all of the resources that is has been given. There is a complexity to it within this region, it is dramatically over budget," she added.
As the row rumbled on into October, Minister Carroll MacNeill pointed out that, since the beginning of the year, CUH had recruited 323 staff, while St James' in Dublin - "the biggest hospital in the country" - only recruited 94 additional staff in the same time.
She questioned why the number of patients being treated on trolleys at CUH remained so consistently high, when recruitment there was the "highest by some distance of any hospital in this country".
Subsequently, the Minister for Health would argue: "To me, it does not seem right or fair that one region might take from another, and how we manage that over time really does matter."
Minister Carroll MacNeill has - through this, and even before this row began - maintained a laser focus on the number of patients being treated on trolleys, making it clear that she wanted steps to reduce trolley figures to be prioritised by each individual hospital.
She clearly is not impressed with CUH and the steps taken there, notwithstanding the level of recruitment that has taken place at the hospital since the beginning of the year.
"The reality is that there are some hospitals that have not improved, that need to improve, and bizarrely, the ones that consistently do not improve, Cork, have had the highest recruitment," she said on 22 October, after Ms Kearney had said that the situation there was "getting worse".
The truth is, though, that Cork University Hospital - like many other HSE facilities nationally - has struggled with its budget for many, many years.
Indeed, consultants at CUH who rallied to back Ms Kearney, made clear their belief that the budgetary issues there were historic, stretching back over a long period of time.
Paediatric Radiologist Dr Michael Breen was quoted by the Irish Examiner, saying: "Patients and frontline staff in Cork and Kerry cannot continue to absorb the consequences of longstanding deficits in staffing, capacity and infrastructure."
The key word there is longstanding. Senior medical staff at CUH believe the hospital has got less than its share of the national budgetary pie for many years.
Chairman of the Consultant Staff Committee, Vascular Surgeon Greg Fulton, did not put a tooth in it in a letter to Minister Carroll MacNeill and the HSE Chief Executive Anne O'Connor at the end of August.
"We believe that this situation has occurred as a result of years of underfunding relative to other similar-sized hospitals. This, we contend, is due, in part, to a recurring desire of previous CUH management over many years to stay within their budget allocation when other hospitals did not," Prof Fulton wrote.
Professor Conor Deasy, who heads up CUH's emergency department, wrote: "I am deeply grateful she (Ms Kearney) has highlighted it for the sake and safety of our patients."
Incidentally, this unanimity between management and senior clinicians at CUH is virtually unprecedented.
Last week, Prof Fulton told RTÉ's Today with David McCullagh radio programme that staff had been "bound together by the absence of support from HSE central".
"I think it's fair to say that staff have been really galvanised by their support for the CEO [Ms Kearney], who's really been very effective in putting patient issues first," he said.
Tensions over budgets have always been an issue at CUH and, indeed, across the health services in general.
What is different about this is that these tensions have overflowed into the public domain, in a way the public rarely gets to see.
In that way, the public owe a debt of gratitude to whoever passed Ms Kearney's letter to RTÉ's Brian O'Connell.
It has opened up a public debate on the type of health service the public wants, as distinct from the type of health service the public gets - and whether the public is getting bang for its buck, despite the billions of euro of taxpayers' money that are being poured into it.
The current debate, though, has afforded the public a peek through the keyhole inside the health service.
Would the public have known, for instance, that women admitted to Cork University Hospital for mastectomy surgeries, some already in hospital gowns, were sent home at short notice when their surgery was cancelled, because the hospital's emergency capacity had become overwhelmed?
Cork East Social Democrats TD Liam Quaide revealed that information on the floor of the Dáil, during an exchange with the Taoiseach.
He also pointed out that colon, brain and prostate cancer surgeries were also cancelled.
"Imagine the stress of those patients," he said.
The debate about the type of care being delivered at CUH is justified, though, because the figures involved here are so significant.
Cork University Hospital serves a population of 1.1 million people. As of September, this year, according to HSE South West, it had 611 adult in-patient beds, 68 paediatric in-patient beds and 43 surge beds, making a total of 722 beds.
The hospital's budget for 2026 is just over €638.5 million, up from €600.5 million last year. In September, it was already €45 million over budget.
It has 5,194 whole-time-equivalent staff on its books to run the hospital, a huge jump from almost 3,500 WTE staff, which it had in 2020.
No one is disputing that substantial additional investment has been pumped into CUH by the taxpayer in recent years.
The question senior clinical staff are asking - the same question that Ms Kearney raised in her letter in August - is whether these staffing numbers are adequate to safely run a hospital of that size, given the equally significant population growth in recent years.
They say neither the Taoiseach, Micheál Martin, nor Minister Carroll MacNeill have so far addressed that question about the adequacy of the staff numbers.
Both have spoken at length and repeatedly about the additional staff numbers that have been recruited at Cork University Hospital in recent times.
But the clinicians say neither has commented on whether the hospital has enough or adequate staff to do what is expected of it.
And, yet, there have been repeated calls from Opposition politicians in the Dáil, and from the nine clinical directors - the most senior doctors - at Cork University Hospital for an independent assessment of staffing needs there, and how those staffing needs measure up against the actual number of staff employed there.
"To be honest, I don't think we need it," was how Ms O'Connor dismissed that call in her interview on the RTÉ This Week programme on Radio 1 last Sunday.
The last time a similar assessment of need was published, in the Government's Acute Hospital Inpatient Bed Capacity Expansion Plan 2024 - 2031, CUH was identified as having the largest deficit of adult inpatient and critical care beds of any hospital in the country.
That supports the clinicians' contention that CUH has been underfunded for many years, relative to other similar-sized hospitals.
Ms O'Connor justified her refusal to sanction an independent staff assessment on the basis that the HSE's own management systems already give her a substantial amount of information on what is happening at CUH.
"Their increase in staffing this year is bigger than the combined increase in Beaumont, the Mater, St James and Tallaght University hospitals," Ms O'Connor told the Oireachtas Health Committee earlier this week.
"We know a lot," Ms O'Connor told the committee. "We can see into our systems."
"We know the number of people that are paid in CUH in September. We can see the numbers across all of our services, across all of our hospitals, and we can see the numbers that are on the payroll today," she added.
Last Sunday, she told the This Week programme on RTÉ: "We know that they have a significant number of staff. The challenge now is to ensure that we have the right staff in the right place at the right time."
The nine clinical directors at CUH are presumably among those who were being criticised this week for airing these issues in public, but in their letter to Mr Martin on 27 October, they made clear that they have been trying to raise their concerns "repeatedly" through the appropriate channels, "yet the issues at the heart of this matter remain unresolved".
"The clinical risks have not been adequately addressed, and the clinicians accountable for patient care do not believe their concerns are being heard," they said, in their letter to Mr Martin.
They clearly feel they are not being listened to.
The same clinical directors are disputing the recruitment figures for CUH being quoted by Minister Carroll MacNeill and HSE management.
This is another reason why they are calling for an independent assessment of staffing at CUH.
Tomorrow, the Taoiseach will meet Ms Kearney and senior clinicians at CUH.
There is talk that Ms O'Connor might attend too.
No doubt, attempts will be made to take some of the oxygen out of this controversy.
The Taoiseach has told the Dáil he briefly met Ms Kearney in October but said he would rather focus on the issues, rather than speaking about individuals.
He said reform is critical, saying that the health budget has gone up exponentially, pointing to the complex care needs of an ageing population.
Mr Martin also defended his engagement with CUH.
"For 30-odd years of my political life, I've been involved with Cork University Hospital," he said, noting there had been engagement between senior HSE officials and CUH management, including a visit by officials on 27 October.
Mr Martin has conceded that "all is not well with CUH" but insisted that he would not be providing a back channel to circumvent Minister Carroll MacNeill in terms of the hospital management's asks.
There is substantial daylight between the sides here: HSE management, Minister Carroll MacNeill and the Government are sticking to their positions that CUH is adequately funded and has recruited enough staff to run the hospital safely; Ms Kearney, the hospital's nine clinical directors and the hospital's consultants' committee are insisting that patient safety risks are still there.
It is going to take quite the diplomacy to bridge the gap between the sides and achieve consensus.
Source: RTÉ News · Paschal Sheehy
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira