Between Nvidia's Hollywood-style scandal and Anthropic's record-breaking market debut, it seemed impossible to hide from AI-related news last week.
In fact, they have dominated headlines since 2022, when OpenAI launched ChatGPT.
There are reasons why every move by a handful of companies – and their powerful leaders – is being watched so closely.
AI firms have dramatically increased their influence on the global economy, and, more specifically, on Ireland's economic fortunes.
"It's the biggest issue in the global economy, and I think it's the biggest issue in global financial markets at the moment," says Goodbody's Chief Economist Dermot O'Leary.
From equity and bond markets to interest rates – there's no corner of global finances not impacted by AI.
Artificial intelligence is now so deeply embedded in the world's financial systems, that "any slowdown in AI investment or profitability could trigger a repricing in financial markets and adversely affect economic activity," the Central Bank of Ireland has warned this week.
In simple words, the AI sector must keep growing, or the shockwaves will be felt around the world.
Why is there so much money in AI and where is it coming from?
In recent months, debate has intensified across global markets over whether the AI boom is veering into bubble territory.
"For me, it's not a question of if the AI bubble will burst, it is when the AI bubble will burst and how bad it will be," said Dr Emma Howard, an economist and lecturer at TU Dublin, who, like many of her colleagues, is concerned about the overvaluation of AI giants.
Anthropic raised $81 billion in its market debut this week, reaching a valuation of around $1.7 trillion.
The maker of chatbot Claude has become the first major standalone AI company to go public.
Unlike SpaceX, which owns tangible and profitable assets like Starlink satellites, or Nvidia, which sells chips, Anthropic's valuation rests chiefly on its AI models.
"Anthropic is a crazy example because they are a company that is loss making and they just floated for this astronomical valuation," says Dr Howard.
Anthropic reported losses of $80.7 billion in the first half of this year, while committing $518 billion in investment over a decade.
The gap between its enormous valuation and continuing losses means investors are still willing to pay for – or, as some would put it, "gamble on" – the hope that AI pioneers will change the world and generate huge revenues in the future.
Goldman Sachs estimates that this year alone the overall AI spending will exceed $1 trillion.
Economists and financial regulators are growing increasingly concerned about where AI giants are finding these funds – and how it is making money more expensive for everyone.
Tech companies cannot fully fund their AI expansion themselves, so they are borrowing more and more.
That, in turn, is putting pressure on other borrowers – especially governments – competing for global capital, which, despite being vast, is not unlimited.
Dermot O'Leary explains that global AI investment has "an impact on longer-term interest rates and government borrowing costs".
Ireland is not immune to that.
Borrowing costs for the Government here have increased this year, though not to the same extent as elsewhere.
AIB pointed out that the yield on Ireland’s 10-year benchmark bond rose from 3.21% in March to 3.50% at its October auction.
Then there's an impact on shareholders.
Anyone investing directly in AI-related businesses would be watching swings in tech stocks closely.
However, funding the AI boom doesn't have to be a conscious choice – Irish pension funds are already doing it on behalf of their customers.
An analysis by RTÉ’s Prime Time showed that as much as €15 of every €100 invested go towards six companies behind the AI boom: Nvidia, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon, Meta and Broadcom.
Why is everyone worried about returns on AI investment?
The biggest question remains how the AI giants will repay their enormous debts.
There is still no proof that artificial intelligence can transform global economies and justify the billions of dollars being poured into it today.
"A lot of the AI that people use day-to-day, they're certainly not paying the true cost of use of it. If you think about the electricity and the data storage cost, we're not paying the true cost of these products," says Dr Emma Howard.
AI's impact on productivity remains hypothetical.
Trinity College, in collaboration with Microsoft, surveyed 250 senior leaders in Ireland for its latest study on AI adoption.
The research found that around 70% of respondents said AI helped them save up to two hours of work time a week.
"As a worker saving two hours a week is pretty valuable, but the price tag that is on the AI expenditure, the cost of the AI, you need to see productivity gains of many, many multiple times that for it to be worth the investment," says Dr Howard.
Goodbody's chief economist Dermor O'Leary said he doesn't "have a crystal ball on that one," but noted that AI companies themselves are "making the call certainly that the returns on this are going to come through".
Ireland and AI: benefits and risks
Ireland's exposure to the AI boom has been unique.
The country has been reaping the rewards through jobs, investment, and economic growth.
According to advisory firm EY it helped Ireland to weather recent economic shocks and kept the country's domestic growth around 3% – double the European average.
EY forecasts similar growth to continue, but only if the AI boom goes on.
The latest analysis by Goodbody estimates that AI has accounted for a 20% of the increase in nominal domestic demand over the past year.
It also shows that Ireland's has the highest data-centre capacity in Europe per capita – 1,732 megawatts of computing power.
We're only behind two much larger nations: Germany and the UK.
Data centres were responsible for 23% of the country's electricity demand last year, causing frustration among local communities and a regulatory pushback from the Government.
Goodbody's Dermot O’Leary believes that failing to ride this "next wave of investment" would have been a mistake for Ireland, damaging the country’s competitive position.
"Particularly because Ireland's in a position where they already house these companies."
"I don't think it's a good message to send out to say that, look, we will keep your office workers and we will take your corporate tax revenue, but you can't put your data centres here."
Yet what is currently a source of strength and economic growth is also, according to the Central Bank, "a key structural vulnerability" potentially impacting tax revenue, value of investments and jobs.
The regulator has warned that if AI valuations fall or investment dries up, the impact on the domestic economy and households could be "significant".
Source: RTÉ News · Tania Reut
At a glance
- Topic
- Business
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira