“Let me now introduce you to Larson’s Law of Lists,” Jeremy D Larson writes on Pitchfork this week. “The first reaction to any list is to point out what is not on it.”

He’s not wrong. Larson’s words come as introduction to that enduringly influential website’s list of 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time. It would be overstating things to suggest it’s as if a chart of 100 best heavy-rock albums failed to include Black Sabbath or Led Zeppelin, but some sort of Jesuitical sophistry does seem to be afoot.

Nothing from The Smiths? Is there a more convincing suggestion for the archetypal “indie” band than those Mancunian depressives? Nothing from either Joy Division or New Order? No Suede?

Larson does offer a bizarre explanation in an attempted definition – he admits many others exist – of this slippery category. “Indie rock is primarily an American musical art form,” he writes. Is it? It’s not jazz or bluegrass. Surely it has as much to do with the Mersey as it does with the Mississippi (and even more with Manchester Ship Canal).

You will look in vain for Aztec Camera or The Jesus and Mary Chain. The list is topped by Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain, by Pavement. Liz Phair, Sonic Youth and Sleater-Kinney flesh out the top 10.

The Stone Roses, among a tiny handful of British bands included, land at number 49 with their renowned first LP. Forty-nine? It would be less insulting to join The Smiths in being left out altogether. Social media is throbbing with fury.

Anyway, this does give us the opportunity to attempt some definition of indie rock and to ponder American music critics’ exhausting obsession with genre.

“Indie” might be the only genre to pass from a classification that had nothing to do with how the music sounded to a loosely defined sonic style. The “indie charts” in music papers such as the New Musical Express were initially concerned simply with records released on independent labels.

[ Jim Reid of The Jesus and Mary Chain: ‘I’m not saying we’re all lovey-dovey: we still scream at each other’Opens in new window ]

True, looking back at the 1980s, we find tunes by such expected funsters as Throbbing Gristle and Pink Military. But we also find Kylie Minogue and Agadoo by Black Lace. That last, famously annoying track succeeded The March Violets’ Walk into the Sun at number one in the UK independent charts in August 1984.

The term did not, in these islands, properly establish itself as something like a musical genre until the very end of the 1980s. Though The Smiths may now seem like indie personified – white blokes warbling over jangly guitars – few people would have described them that way before their dissolution, in 1987. That term stuck itself to successors such as The Wonder Stuff, Happy Mondays and The Stone Roses.

[ Shaun Ryder: ‘Bez and I have had a sexless marriage for 32 years. I’m with him all the time’Opens in new window ]

Andy Burnham, who would have been 19 when the Roses released their classic debut, has been described as the UK’s first indie prime minister, but The Economist isn’t quite buying it. “An indie establishment has long held sway among British politicians who came of age in the 1980s,” the magazine noted in July, observing that both Keir Starmer and David Cameron were fans of The Smiths.

Yet few artists would describe themselves as indie in the way others might call themselves folk musicians or metal heads. The term is too diffuse to allow easy definition. Are Blur indie? Sort of. Are Oasis indie? Maybe, before they began playing stadiums. Are all postpunk artists pre-indie? The late Mark E Smith of The Fall would surely abhor the suggestion. In Britain and Ireland indie is used loosely to describe an attitude as much as a school of music.

It is different in the United States, where, as a nation that likes to keep stuff in boxes, musical genres are treated with enormous seriousness (by pundits if not the musicians themselves).

The average US reviewer has long been in the habit of approaching pop criticism as an etymologist might address a bug. Measure the thorax. Count the joints. Determine what class (or species) to which the record (or insect) belongs. Genres spawn subgenres. Subgenres spawn microgenres.

[ Sonic Youth’s Kim Gordon: ‘The word ‘icon’ is a little uncomfortable’Opens in new window ]

An excellent parlour game – let’s call it genre bingo – has one player challenge his equally sad pal to identify an act from only its listed genres on Wikipedia.

Ready? Dream pop, ethereal wave, gothic rock and postpunk? It’s Scotland’s mighty Cocteau Twins. Bet you never knew you liked ethereal wave.

[ Fontaines DC: ‘We just hang out with ourselves and don’t really interact as much with other people’Opens in new window ]

Another? Indie rock, postpunk, crank wave and alternative rock? It is our own Fontaines DC, of course. If you’re interested, crank wave is “also known as the post-Brexit new wave or wonk”.

This is all enormously silly. Like the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, such formalisation only strips the music of renegade status and accords it uneeded respectability. Indie rock, nein danke.

Source: The Irish Times · Donald Clarke

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira