Editorial

November 22, 2026 — 7:30pm

Those involved in horse racing must be thanking their lucky stars that cricket exists. Thanks to the explosion of Sandpapergate, thoroughbred racing has been able to duck under the cover of being the second-biggest scandal to engulf Australian sport in the past week.

For all the sound and fury that has accompanied the eight-year-old ball-tampering scandal, and the reopening of wounds that have never been allowed to heal fully, equal if not greater opprobrium should be meted out to those who have built an industry around horseflesh.

So You Are, ridden by Rachel King, on its way to the barriers before competing in the Melbourne Cup at Flemington earlier this month.Racing Photos via Getty Images

The cruelty of horse racing was laid bare in the last seven days. A dead horse was found in a skip with an old couch.

It should have sent a chill through the heart of any animal lover. Any thinking, feeling human being. The carcass found at the Cleanaway Lucas Heights Resource Recovery Centre was a gelding that ran eighth in the Melbourne Cup, and this fact ought to shake the thoroughbred racing industry into action.

Two weeks after what Mark Twain described, during a trip to Melbourne, as a “delirium of colour, a vision of beauty” made its annual eruption at Flemington, the grim fate of So You Are in a bin on Sydney’s southern outskirts revealed the industry’s greatest flaw: its treatment of the animals it profits from.

So You Are was a five-year-old whose winnings totalled $1.4 million, and owners, trainers, jockeys and punters alike were left horrified at learning the fate that befell him. Owner and breeder Stuart Ramsey described it as the “worst thing to happen in my lifetime” and described trainer Bjorn Baker as being distraught.

For his part, Racing NSW chief executive Graeme Hinton called So You Are’s treatment after death “totally unacceptable”, promised a swift and decisive review to determine whether stricter standards were needed and vowed to push for a national approach.

Hinton, who is due to start officially on December 1 but has the reins as outgoing chief Peter V’landys is on leave, offered strong words. These must be backed up with action if the state’s $3.3 billion industry is to maintain credibility.

The message was certainly more encouraging than what we heard from the state government. Racing Minister David Harris last Tuesday afternoon described it as a “concerning incident” in a statement that distanced the government from welfare matters and offered that the investigation made it “inappropriate to comment further at this time”.

Premier Chris Minns was better on Wednesday morning, acknowledging the discovery was distressing and urging a full investigation. “We expect these things not to happen,” he said.

But Minns’ government has the chance to act. An independent review of the 30-year-old Thoroughbred Racing Act by former minister Brad Hazzard has been with the cabinet since July.

While its conclusions remain under wraps, transparency, accountability, jockey and animal welfare were all within Hazzard’s scope.

In NSW, thoroughbred racing has been ringfenced from scrutiny as political fights have centred on greyhounds. During the week, much focus has been on the cricket, but the racing industry should be placed on notice. The horses deserve better.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

From our partners

Source: The Sydney Morning Herald · The Herald's View

At a glance

Topic
Sports
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira