November 19, 2026 — 7:30pm
Redevelopment is shrinking housing supply in some of Sydney’s most densely populated suburbs as older apartment blocks are replaced with fewer, larger and more expensive apartments.
As the state continues to fall further behind its housing supply target, audits from several councils including Randwick, City of Sydney, Woollahra and Waverley show a number of redevelopments have delivered a net loss of homes.
The growing trend will create another headache for the Minns government, which has pinned its hopes of boosting housing supply on increasing density in inner-city suburbs.
Two council reports concluded the government’s low-and-mid-rise policy would accelerate the loss of homes.
In a report released last month, Randwick council identified 19 developments built since 2018 which resulted in the net loss of 86 homes across the local government area.
It also found the issue was becoming more prevalent in high-demand, high-value inner metropolitan areas.
“Council has identified an emerging redevelopment trend, evident in neighbouring LGAs and increasingly within the Randwick LGA, where [rental flat buildings] are being replaced by developments containing fewer dwellings,” the report said.
While those developments represented a fraction of the 782 developments over the eight-year period, the number of developments causing a net loss of homes had doubled from six in the first three years compared to 13 between 2022 and 2026.
In one example, a Coogee complex with eight apartments was demolished and replaced with a new development containing four homes.
Randwick mayor Clare Willington said: “In a housing crisis, we should be adding homes, not losing them. Knocking down three homes to build one is the wrong way around.”
“The homes we’re losing are the more affordable ones: older flats that renters, young people, key workers and downsizers target.”
The report found the state government’s low-and-mid-rise or “missing middle” reforms were likely to accelerate the rate of net home loss.
While the policy was intended to deliver 112,000 homes, the council’s report found the provision of additional floor space and development capacity did not guarantee an increase in the number of homes delivered on every redeveloped site.
In response to questions, Planning Minister Paul Scully said the suggestion the missing middle reforms would accelerate net dwelling loss “does not stack up”, and councils could introduce bespoke policies when there were real issues.
“Loss of existing dwellings through redevelopment generally occurs in a relatively small number of high-value local government areas with a high volume of existing older medium and high-density housing, where strong market demand and land values can create pressure to replace existing housing stock,” he said.
A Woollahra Council report released in October last year also examined the issue of redevelopments causing a net loss in homes.
“Staff also expect that the low and mid-rise housing reforms which commenced on 28 February 2025 will accelerate this issue,” the Woollahra report said.
The council identified 35 DAs lodged between 2020 and 2025 which cumulatively resulted in the loss of 83 dwellings. If approved, a further seven DAs being assessed would cause a further net loss of 10 homes.
The council was increasingly concerned the net dwelling loss would reduce housing supply, finding it has an “incremental and cumulative impact” on its ability to meet its dwelling targets.
“Without a change to the planning controls, we expect that occurrences of net dwelling loss will increase, and accordingly there is strategic merit in preparing a planning proposal to proactively address this issue,” the Woollahra council report concluded.
It also found there had been a 1 per cent decline in one-bedroom and studio dwellings across the council area, compared to four-bedroom homes which grew by 18 per cent. Conversely, the report found these smaller homes have been the fastest growing type of housing across Greater Sydney over the preceding decade.
“This not only results in a reduction in the dwelling yield on the site, but also means that the new housing delivered is more expensive, and the mix of dwelling sizes may be less diverse,” it found.
In 2024, a report released by City of Sydney identified 25 DAs which had resulted in the loss of 65 homes.
A further eight development applications that were being assessed when the report was published would cause a reduction of a total of 143 dwellings if they proceeded.
“Notably, these all involve large-scale redevelopment of residential flat buildings of between seven and 80 apartments and continue to be concentrated in the City’s east,” the council’s report found.
During a Randwick council meeting on Tuesday, councillors endorsed a planning proposal restricting new developments to either a single dwelling loss or 15 per cent of the existing total — whatever is greater. The proposal mirrored controls adopted by City of Sydney and Woollahra Council.
“Council is moving to stop redevelopment from shrinking Randwick City’s housing supply,” the council wrote on Wednesday.
In September, the Herald revealed the Minns government was miles behind its commitment to build 112,000 “missing middle” homes by July 2029, with only 3 per cent of the targeted homes having development applications approved.
Analysis by University of Sydney Emeritus Professor Peter Phibbs showed the planning pathway was largely being used for renovations of standalone houses or the construction of detached houses.
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
From our partners
Source: The Sydney Morning Herald · Max Maddison
At a glance
- Topic
- Politics
- Country
- 🇦🇺 AU
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira