Editorial
November 18, 2026 — 5:00am
The early voting centres open on Wednesday in the rundown to the state election on November 28. According to the latest Resolve Political Monitor, Labor has a primary vote of 20 per cent, the Coalition 30 per cent and One Nation 23 per cent.
In these remaining days, The Age will continue to look closely at what we believe are the five main areas of state government influence: health, transport, crime, education, and planning and property.
Directly or indirectly, deeply or slightly, each area has an impact on Victorians, and on the size and priorities of the budget, and how taxpayers’ money is spent. We will examine the parties’ positions as they affect the state. Two primary measures of this assessment will be good financial management and integrity. Both go to the core of competent government.
With Labor, its position via campaign promises is twinned with its record in government; with the opposition it is, obviously, only through policies presented as campaign announcements. The Coalition was last in power from 2010 to 2014, its only term this century. To draw its actions then with now is too long a bow.
While crime, especially in Melbourne, and transport (from the scandals of the Big Build, now being held to account in the royal commission following our reporting, to the epidemic of potholes statewide) have taken a lot of the oxygen in public exposure and debate, justifiably and understandably so, the other areas must not fall by the wayside. The largest area of these is the health system. And it is unwell.
The state Department of Health’s budget, at more than $30 billion, is the biggest of all budgets, followed by Education, the Department of Justice and Community Safety and the Department of Transport and Planning. As shown by our reporting, the health system is in major need of repair and maintenance.
At Labor’s campaign launch on Sunday, Premier Ben Carroll promised almost $1.4 billion for the public health system in an extra 100,000 planned surgeries, and the specialist appointments for them over the next four years. The Coalition has promised almost $1.3 billion to the private sector to deliver another 25,000 surgeries a year.
While welcome, these pledges stand in contrast to a recent report in The Age highlighting the system’s dire straits. In a report to state parliament were the following statistics: ambulances were missing key response targets; only two-thirds of critical code 1 emergencies were responded to within 15 minutes. Though an improvement on last year, this was well below the benchmark of 85 per cent. On ramping, only 71 per cent of patients were transferred from ambulances to emergency departments within 40 minutes. The target is 80 per cent. In relation to Triple Zero calls, 80 per cent of code 1 ambulance cases were dispatched within the 2½-minute standard; the benchmark is 90 per cent. Triple Zero regularly dealt with 3000 ambulance calls a day.
Three years ago, we wrote in an editorial, “It is absolutely unacceptable for suspected stroke or heart attack patients to be spending more than an hour on ambulance trolleys awaiting critical diagnosis and treatment.”
The cities are not the only areas being affected. In September, we reported on failures of the system at Mildura Base Public Hospital, with an investigation into lengthy and potentially fatal delays.
The situation with forensic mental health is also dire. The Age has consistently reported and editorialised on the plight of the mentally ill in this state and the services, or lack thereof, available to them. One tragic example is two youth suicide clusters in Melbourne’s east.
In our election editorial of November 2022, following questions put to candidates and leaders on what people wanted answered, we wrote, “On health, we were disappointed that neither side wants to address the system’s structural failings.”
The minor parties have been unable to cut through with their policies but for the Greens unveiling a plan to make dental care free in Victoria. Labor sought to match this with a promise of its own of 20 free clinics.
If a structure is not built or maintained to meet the demands of its environment, then it will fail. Good government is more than aiming for the screaming headlines of promising the world for a vote. It is about the unglamorous side of politics, of having the courage to make the structural changes that are necessary to make society a better place for everyone. This ambition is rooted in integrity of intent. We will be watching.
Get a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own. Sign up for our Opinion newsletter.
From our partners
Source: The Age · The Age's View
At a glance
- Topic
- Politics
- Country
- 🇦🇺 AU
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira