A colleague shared a humorous memory this week involving a regional bureau radio host fooled by a caller who claimed he was part of a team responsible for the Bureau of Meteorology's (BOM) Apparent Temperature (AT).
According to the listener, it was his job to judge how the temperature feels, then report that figure to the bureau.
Calculating the perceived temperature is far from straightforward. (ABC News: Liam Patrick)
The presenter, live on air, fell for it and was impressed at the caller's dedication to accuracy, and how his team prepares, including but not restricted to — having a good blood temperature, wearing appropriate seasonal clothing, and never coming to work with a cold.
And while I can categorically confirm the bureau does not hire thousands of people to stand beside weather stations all day, calculating the perceived temperature is nonetheless far from straightforward.
A complex answer to a simple problem
"Hey Tom, is it hot or cold outside?"
I dread this question more than most because the answer is influenced by multiple factors.
Air temperature, a measure of how fast air molecules are moving, is the most basic way to describe heat, but it's only one factor in determining thermal comfort, and using it in isolation can lead to a misjudgement of both wardrobe requirements and the suitability of outdoor activities.
Humidity, wind, sunshine, time of year, activity level, clothing, age and health also play a part.
BOMs purpose is to describe the weather outdoors for everyone. (ABC News: Liam Patrick)
High humidity makes it feel warmer, but high wind speeds make it feel cooler.
An active fully clothed body will quickly heat, while a naked, wet body will soon be shivering.
Direct sunlight makes it feel hotter, but the impact varies by month due to the sun's migrating angle.
This is why the original question makes me anxious. Is the enquirer heading into the summer sun, or the chilling underground wind tunnel at Parramatta station's concourse?
So with all that in mind, what should Australians rely on this summer to stay comfortable during what's likely to be one of the hottest seasons on record?
Dozens of indices have been developed around the world to solve this problem, many of which are tailored for a specific purpose like the Excess Heat Factor for multi-day heatwaves, the Sports Heat Tool for stress during vigorous activity and the Thermal Work Limit for a sustainable work rate in industrial settings.
But the figures on the BOM's website serve a broader purpose: describing the weather outdoors for everyone.
Australia readies for one of the hottest seasons on record. (ABC News: Floss Adams)
Apparent temperature and shade far more useful than the forecast maximum
To provide a more accurate measurement than ambient temperature alone, the BOM publishes two thermal comfort observations, the Wet Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT) and the Apparent Temperature (AT).
But there's a subtle difference between the two. WBGT is measured directly using instruments that respond physically to heat, humidity, wind and sun, while AT is calculated from observations using a formula that approximates a model of the human body.
Proximity to water affects the apparent temperature. (ABC News: Warwick Ford)
However, the BOM's WBGT is an approximation that assumes sunny, light-wind conditions, whereas its AT uses the wind and humidity actually measured and is also displayed on the BOM's standard current observation pages.
Before I explain how the AT is calculated, let me demonstrate why it matters.
Consider 25 degrees Celsius with contrasting wind, humidity and cloud conditions:
- At 25C, 100 per cent humidity, and no wind it would feel like 39C to an adult standing in the sun during the middle of a summer day.
- At 25C, 20 per cent humidity, overcast skies and gale force winds it would feel like 11C.
That's nearly a 30C difference at the exact same ambient temperature.
Is it hot outside? Well it depends who you ask, says ABC meteorologist Tom Saunders. (ABC News: Floss Adams)
Here is a step-by-step summary of how the BOM arrives at the final figure
The AT is defined as the temperature that would cause the same level of discomfort at a standard humidity as the current combination of temperature, humidity and wind.
It is based on a mathematical model of an adult walking outdoors in the shade, with assumptions about body type, clothing and activity level, and calibrated for healthy adults.
Next comes the tricky part, the formula. AT = Ta + 0.33xe − 0.70xws − 4.00
Let's break it down term by term
- Ta is the air temperature.
- e is the water vapour pressure, which is humidity (not the same as relative humidity). So 0.33e implies for every 3hPa increase in pressure from moisture, it feels 1C warmer.
- ws is wind speed in metres per second, so using a conversion, for every 5km/h increase in wind it feels 1C cooler.
- The -4.00 is a constant that forces the result to fit adult walking the model
- A critical missing term in this equation is absorbed radiation — so the effect of the sun directly heating your skin. However, the BOM omit radiation, partly because it would make the calculation inaccurate and inconsistent with standard observations and forecasts aligned to shade. Essentially this means if exposed to direct sunlight, up to another 8C should be added to the AT.
No, BOM does not hire thousands of people to stand besides weather stations. (ABC News: Floss Adams)
Is wind chill, feels like temperature and the heat index different?
But what about the other published temperature indexes found online or in Apps?
The commonly used Heat Index, developed in the USA, is similar to the BOM's AT, as is the Canadian Humidex, but they only factor in humidity and not wind, so they are most useful in hot weather.
Similarly, wind chill, commonly used in Northern Hemisphere winter climates, is mostly relevant to cold weather.
The term "feels like temperature" is non-scientific and could be referencing any index, but it's the same as the AT in BOM products.
The feels-like temperature is also a version of AT on the UK Met Office and NZ MetService websites, although the formula and, therefore, the figures differ from the BOM's. So, once again, it really depends on who you ask.
Source: ABC Australia · Tom Saunders
At a glance
- Topic
- Science
- Country
- 🇦🇺 AU
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira