November 20, 2026 — 3:00am

While amalgamations are at the forefront of Perth councils minds, one western suburbs local government believes they shouldn’t have to foot the $100,000 bill to examine its feasibility.

The Town of Cottesloe will consider a motion at its next meeting to transfer the financial burden to the state government instead of ratepayers.

WA Local Government Minister Hannah Beazley says councils should jump on voluntary amalgamations.Trevor Collens

But a state government spokesperson told this masthead that local councils “need to put some skin in the game” and bear the brunt of the costs themselves.

Town officers have recommended ahead of next Tuesday’s council meeting that councillors vote to advise the state government that it is “willing to participate in discussions regarding potential local government amalgamation where it can be demonstrated that the proposal would deliver improved services, financial sustainability and community outcomes.”

However, it comes with the condition that they also request the Cook government fully fund the preparation of any business case as the six-figure bill would impose an “unreasonable financial burden on ratepayers for an initiative that arises from a state government policy objective.”

“A rigorous independent assessment is essential before Council, the community or the state government can reasonably determine whether amalgamation would be in the public interest,” Town officers said.

“The preparation of a business case is not a routine operational activity of local government. There is a strong argument that the state government should bear the full cost of undertaking this assessment.

“Requiring local governments to fund such investigations would effectively transfer the financial burden of state-led reform to local ratepayers, irrespective of whether an amalgamation ultimately proceeds or delivers community benefit.”

A state government spokesperson said local governments need to take responsibility for their own futures and demonstrate leadership when considering structural reform.

“They have a responsibility to determine if they are still fit for purpose, not just for today but in the years and decades ahead,” the spokesperson said.

“Ratepayers deserve decisions based on facts, not assumptions or speculation. They deserve to know what structural reform could mean for their rates, services, assets, workforce, representation and the long-term sustainability of their local government.

“An independent business case is not an unnecessary expense, it is a responsible and essential investment in good governance and decision-making.

“The state government should not be expected to fund every preliminary investigation or business case initiated by local governments, they must be prepared to put some skin in the game.”

The topic of amalgamations has been discussed at most western suburbs councils after the Town of Claremont mayor wrote to each neighbouring local government proposing discussions on the topic in October.

Town of Claremont mayor Peter Telford said he welcomed a meeting with fellow mayors to “discuss possible boundary changes and the concept of a larger local government.”

“Council has authorised discussion without endorsing any particular model of boundary change. An initial meeting would allow us to hear each other’s views and identify what information would help us assess the concept,” Telford wrote.

Three western suburbs councils have taken a clear stance against amalgamating, each noting financial concerns as the primary factor in their decisions.

The City of Nedlands’ mayor Leonie Browner said on November 4 that the City would be focusing firmly on understanding and bolstering its financial position for the next year or two before considering an amalgamation.

“Elected members recently discussed council amalgamations and concluded that for now we must continue to focus on the immediate practical needs of our residents, rather than longer-term issues such as amalgamations,” Browner said.

“Our goal is to rebuild and strengthen the whole organisation to better serve our community.

“Any conversation around amalgamations has to carefully consider the views of our community and the factors that will be critical to delivering long-term benefits for residents such as: communities of interest, demographic trends, existing infrastructure and long term financial sustainability.”

Meanwhile, the Town of Cambridge council decided at its meeting at the end of October that it would not entertain any amalgamation proposals from financially troubled councils.

The council unanimously voted to support a motion which would maintain the current municipal boundaries and not initiate or pursue an amalgamation proposal unless it could “demonstrate a clear net benefit to the Town and its community”.

In the same month, the City of Subiaco mayor David McMullen also announced that they were not considering amalgamation with another local government.

“Local governments succeed and fail based on how effectively they use available resources, the quality of their governance, and the services and outcomes they deliver for their communities,” he said.

“Subiaco is financially secure, efficiently run, and well governed. We have quality services and infrastructure and continue to invest in our community and modernise the way the City operates.”

“Reform and collaboration don’t necessarily require amalgamation. Existing partnerships demonstrate what local governments can achieve by working together, irrespective of their individual size or boundaries.”

The Town of Cottesloe will vote on the amalgamation motion at their November 24 council meeting.

From our partners

Source: The Sydney Morning Herald · Indigo Lemay-Conway

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira