On November 6, Russell Brand was convicted of rape. In the days following, Brand’s fellow waning British comedian David Walliams was accused of grooming teenage girls. Who on earth could have seen this coming? Well, everyone.
Brand’s sentence of 10 years and six months in prison was the culmination of years of accusations against the once-popular personality, whose “cheeky” behaviour was routinely celebrated in the media. I work in comedy and TV in Australia, and have never even been to the UK, but I knew the rumours surrounding Brand and Walliams. The whisper network has talked about them for years.
Brand and Walliams were also seemingly telling us to our faces – on TV and the radio – about the very crimes they are now denying. Following the news of the last few weeks, clips have been surfacing on social media that shine a light on this behaviour, and on those who encouraged it, and on those who let it slide.
One clip shows Brand having a fun conversation with another “hiding in plain sight” predator, Jimmy Savile, on BBC radio, in which he proposes sending over his young female assistant for Savile to use sexually. There’s a clip of TV host Jonathan Ross on stage at the 2004 British Comedy Awards making a joke about how Walliams sleeps with 15-year-olds. There’s Walliams with TV host Jimmy Carr in 2009 on panel show 8 Out of 10 Cats, making a joke about sleeping with teenage boys. And there’s Ross again, setting up Brand and Noel Fielding for a series of rape jokes at Lily Allen’s expense in a 2007 episode of Big Fat Quiz of the Year.
Lily Allen has spoken about that clip, saying, “And I laugh along with it. In retrospect, that’s really horrendous. It makes me uncomfortable, but I don’t think I felt that at the time, because it was the culture.”
Ross has since told The Guardian he was “horrified” and “genuinely unaware” of the crimes of Brand and the revelations about Walliams. He also said it was “deeply shocking” to be shown footage from the comedy awards. Fielding, who now co-hosts The Great British Bake Off, has also spoken out, telling The Sun newspaper he was “appalled” at “some of the jokes I made alongside him [Brand] … They were horrible and inappropriate, and I very much regret them”.
Walliams’ lawyers, meanwhile, told The Guardian that, “These are jokes … and are not statements of fact. Many of the jokes that you have referred to were written or delivered by [Walliams’] good friends.”
For me, it’s the laughter in these clips that is particularly unsettling, because it suggests a shared understanding. This type of joke works for these men because their audience recognises truth in what they are saying. The shared laughter comes from the knowledge that someone is getting away with something. Women are always the object of these jokes, even if the joke is about a man’s behaviour. Women are never allowed in on the joke, despite being unavoidably in on the truth behind it.
The truth is coming out now. Days after Brand was sentenced to 10 years in jail, The Guardian published a detailed investigation into Walliams with claims he groomed teenage fans and sexually assaulted a 15-year-old girl (allegations he denies).
Then, comedian Lucy Beaumont came forward as one of the whistleblowers. She claims a young man had informed her he was uncomfortable being asked to bring young women to the former Little Britain star. She says she spoke to one of the young girls, who was “in a really bad way”, and had allegedly signed an NDA, meaning she couldn’t talk to anybody about it. Lucy felt compelled to bring all this forward, knowing it would mean getting less work in the future.
In the comedy, television and arts industries, it is still a lot about who you know, and how those people feel towards you. If you’re the person to point out the problem everyone knows about and has tacitly agreed to ignore, you become the difficult one. If you speak out about the treatment of women, you become the one ruining the fun. Women are left to make an almost impossible calculation: do I say something about what I’ve heard, seen or felt? Do I risk my already difficult and tenuous career to try and bring down a powerful man, knowing the people in charge have likely already heard such claims and have done nothing?
I mostly know Beaumont from watching her on Taskmaster, where I fell in love with her. She is kooky and absurd. This isn’t a comedian who is out on the stage doing political comedy. I am 100 per cent positive that she doesn’t want to be going through all this. I’m sure she’d prefer to go out and do her job, like her male peers, without having to weigh her care for women’s safety against her ability to earn a living. As usual, the onus falls on women to make themselves safer from men.
I want to believe it’s not as bad now as it was in the 2000s, when men like Brand and Walliams were at their peak. That was an era where you could make rape jokes on British television, and it would be considered a bit of fun.
It’s worth remembering that it was also the era when Walliams could get away with performing in blackface on his sketch show Little Britain, which he created with Matt Lucas. Those episodes, which also contained racial stereotypes, were removed from the BBC and Australian screens in 2020, while some of Walliams’ other work was removed from the ABC last week.
I do wonder if we have fundamentally changed the culture, or if we’ve just become better at recognising the reputational consequences of being seen to participate in it. Could Brand and Walliams have been taken down if they were still at the peak of their careers?
Many men today would speak out against these kinds of jokes, this behaviour. But in the last couple of months, Shane Gillis has called women “whores” on SNL, and Daniel Sloss – recently lauded for his viral clip encouraging men to challenge other men’s misogyny – has had to apologise for laughing at a terrible rape joke about a rape victim. I don’t think these men are predators, but they don’t give us particularly encouraging signs of change.
So many straight white men in particular still benefit from the social networks of comedy, of their relationships with other men in and around the creative industries. There are also many rising male stars who are willing to turn a blind eye to anything in order to get closer to that success.
I keep coming back to those clips. The laughter, the easy familiarity, the complete absence of shame. These men weren’t whispering in dark corners. They were doing it in public. And yet, time and again, it is women who are expected to do the uncomfortable, thankless, often dangerous work of holding men accountable. It’s women who risk their careers, their reputations and their wellbeing to bring to the surface what everyone has already been told.
Meanwhile, those who laughed, looked away, continued to hire these men and kept the machinery running are allowed to carry on as though none of it had anything to do with them. The culture may have changed, but has anything really been addressed?
Rebecca Shaw is a writer who lives in Sydney. You can find her everywhere at @brocklesnitch
Source: The Sydney Morning Herald · Rebecca Shaw
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇦🇺 AU
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira