A forensic psychologist has cast doubt over a 16-year-old boy's claim that he does not remember fatally stabbing a vulnerable man with an acquired brain injury at an Illawarra train station.

The teenager sat in the dock at the NSW Supreme Court in Wollongong for the second day of his sentence hearing today, after he pleaded guilty in August to murdering Jack Westren on January 28 last year.

Forensic psychologist Katie Seidler gave evidence about the offender's background, intellectual disability and upbringing.

Dr Seidler said the boy told her he had no memory of the incident from the time he was driven to Shellharbour Junction train station, where the offence took place, until his arrest the next day.

The psychologist said it "doesn't make sense clinically" that the offender did not remember the murder when considering all of the evidence, including CCTV footage showing the teenagers violently ambushing Mr Westren.

"My view is that he doesn't want to remember it, he doesn't want to think about it," Dr Seidler said.

"His life is seriously changed now as a result of that behaviour. 

"Psychologically, it's easier for him to not think about that without any great depth."

flowers on a pole

Flowers left behind at Shellharbour Train Station where Jack Westren was fatally stabbed.  (ABC Illawarra: Tim Fernandez)

Dr Seidler said the offender's intellectual disability meant he could not easily consider the impact of his actions or other people's experiences and emotions.

The forensic psychologist said the teenager held antisocial beliefs that drug use, truancy, assaulting someone with his mates, and using cannabis with his parents was acceptable.

"His parents believed it was acceptable to buy a gun," she said, referring to a gel blaster the offender bought while on an interstate holiday.

Dr Seidler told the court there was no evidence the boy previously had homicidal thoughts or that he had a specific intention to kill Mr Westren, and rather that he believed it "would be fun" to go "bash this guy" with his friends.

Tendered court documents state the offender was part of a group of teenagers aged between 13 and 16 who planned to ambush Mr Westren after they sent him messages on social media like "I want you" the night before.

Police walk through grass with police tape tied to pole

The victim was found at a walkway on Shellharbour Road at Dunmore on Tuesday afternoon.  (Supplied: Darren Malone)

Mr Westren was under the belief the messages were being sent by a girl named "Amy".

Instead, he was met by the group of teenagers who assaulted him from behind and repeatedly kicked him while he was on the ground.

The 16-year-old stabbed Mr Westren in the abdomen with a hunting knife, causing him to die at the scene.

Lawyers' submissions

Defence barrister Talitha Hennesy argued the offender had been ambivalent about the plan to ambush Mr Westren, and that he had been "going with the flow" of his co-offenders.

She said the child was influenced into taking a knife and was given a shirt to cover his face by an adult, describing his actions during the assault as reactive and impulsive.

However, Crown prosecutor Nerissa Keay argued the offender did have an intent to kill.

"It is a full use of force, it was deliberate, he walked straight up to him, and that's what he did," she said.

"Given where he stabbed him and the knife that he used, the only rational inference is that he intended to kill him."

A young man in a cap wears a jacket as he stands on a boat at sea.

Six minors were charged over the fatal stabbing of Jack Westren in 2025. (Supplied: Simone Westren)

Ms Keay added that Mr Westren's vulnerabilities would have been easy to comprehend due to the manner in which he communicated and it taking him hours to arrive at the destination.

"It is not difficult to comprehend that someone is lonely, that they have difficulties getting to a place, that he is alone, that he is unprotected," Ms Keay said.

"The group did exploit his vulnerability."

Justice Hament Dhanji reserved his decision for December 17.

Four boys and one girl who pleaded guilty to manslaughter over their roles in the incident will be sentenced in early December.

Source: ABC Australia · Grace Crivellaro

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira