November 16, 2026 — 8:00pm

Megan Herbert

To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@theage.com.au. Please include your home address and telephone number below your letter. No attachments. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published.

VICTORIAN ELECTION

The trouble with Labor’s promises is that no one believes them any more (“Labor and Coalition focus on health, crime”, 16/11). All they succeed in doing is to remind us of the State Electricity Commission which was going to save us money on our power bills and the Commonwealth Games that would bring prosperity to regional Victoria.
Ivan Glynn, Vermont

Curb your enthusiasm
I am voting for the party with the lowest number of promises. It will keep my disappointment to a minimum when they don’t deliver.
Mark de Roy, Montrose

Give nature its due
The major parties’ market research seems to have identified health and crime, along with the cost-of-living, as the issues uppermost in voters’ minds (″⁣Labor and Coalition focus on health, crime,″⁣ 16/11). That’s no great surprise. They’re perennial candidates for attention at election time.
One item that’s a chronic ‘bridesmaid rather than bride’ is nature, yet how it’s cared for and enjoyed has direct implications for our social wellbeing.
Tuning in to nature, appreciating its wonders, listening to its sounds, breathing in its air, and realising our affinity with its age-old rhythms are the best prescription anyone can write for a healthy and peaceful community.
Voters would serve their own interests well by supporting those who give nature its due.
Tom Knowles, Parkville

How will we get to the outer suburbs?
We are told that voters prefer the Liberals’ option of expanded outer suburbs and further density in the CBD.
Will that require the spokes of our rail network to be extended? Perhaps we will need some sort of rail loop to connect a few of those corridors?
Heather Glassford, Williamstown

Dim view of the future
There is no bright future for us if One Nation is looking like a meaningful alternative. Even worse with Labor and Liberals, both happily embracing a neoliberal agenda for the last 30 years.
A reset is required to save us from the steep downhill we are already on – and it’s highly unlikely from what we saw and heard so far. Good luck to all of us.
Bosko Marojevic, Williamstown

Don’t vote, but don’t later complain
I hear around the traps some people will vote informal at the election. Not much good complaining after the horse has bolted.
People in the past, fought long and hard to be where we are today. Once, women and Indigenous people could not vote. Unions fought long and hard for an eight-hour day.
People over the years fought for our privileges. It’s an indictment on society to not vote, or vote on single issues that bother you.
Maybe some should read the political history of times past. Don’t waste your vote, if you do don’t complain when things don’t go your way.
Nola Cormick, Albert Park

More promises, and then some
Ben Carroll may well be “behind in the last quarter” and for understandable reasons, but it’s due to his integrity we are gaining insights into the money and power given to CFMEU by his predecessor as premier.
And, then he goes and throws money around at three footy clubs, including his own?
Bernadette George, Mildura

THE FORUM

Dip into AUKUS spend
Tim Wilson considers the outlook for the housing market to be dire (″⁣Coalition call for repeal of tax changes″⁣, 16/11). I consider the recent pullback in housing prices to give a glimmer of hope for people like my children who are trying to buy their first home.
It all depends on the side of the fence you are on, Tim. If the concerns are about supply coming on stream, the answers are there. Encourage factory built micro housing and developments, government investment in social and low-cost housing, tax penalties on land banking and reducing charges on new housing developments so they become economically viable.
This will cost, of course. How about the Liberals working with Labor to extract ourselves from the AUKUS mess? We would then have plenty of cash.
Barry Lizmore, Ocean Grove

Northcote example
I am growing tired of Tim Wilson’s one-dimensional view of the property market and economy at large. Think outside the square Tim, and consider property developers might like to replicate the model used at Merri Northcote to keep them and many others in work and increase our housing stock. There were 60.4per cent private (151) homes; and 39.6 per cent (99) social housing homes built. The upper end of the private dwellings commanded prices above $2.5million.
I believe you underestimate the taxpayer willingness to contribute to such projects and the benefit it provides communities.
Julie More, Northcote

Worm has turned
What a masterstroke! Paul Keating introduced compulsory superannuation in Australia from July 1, 1992 under the provisions of the federal Superannuation Guarantee system.
This benefit, which applies to all eligible employees, has grown from about $150 billion at June 30, 1992 to approximately $5 trillion today, an increase of over 3000 per cent.
It has now reached the stage where superannuation funds hold so much money invested in companies by way of shareholdings and loans and have such financial clout that they can influence how companies operate.
For example, some superannuation funds will no longer invest in industries which detrimentally affect the environment, e.g. coal or gas and have been known to press boards to introduce environmentally friendly policies under threat of shareholder action.
What was once the ‘big end of town’ and called the shots, is now being dictated to by super funds, a lot of which are ‘industry funds’ i.e. union based. Oh, how the worm has turned.
Stan Thomson, Sandringham

Welfare assumptions
There are assumptions and withheld information in Parnell Palme McGuinnness’ article (″⁣Mum’s post sparks welfare debates″⁣, 15/11) that need calling out. Although sympathetic to the concept of financial support when hard times come calling, Palme McGuinness appears to believe that Centrelink payments are adequate, which any recipient could tell you they are not.
For example, if Jenn, the single, jobless parent whose post gave rise to the article, had to leave her present accommodation, probably at least 60 per cent of her total quoted income of $4124 per month would be required to rent a house. This would leave her about $400a week for groceries, utilities, transport, insurance, health care, clothes etc.
We are not told the employment status of the two workers cited, whose incomes are allegedly less than the jobless parent. Do they have children, which would mean eligibility for Centrelink payments on their incomes? Do they have partners? Are their salaries before or after tax, and on the pay cited, they would most likely get back almost all tax paid.
Palme McGuinness ignores the fact that being employed, they would receive four weeks pro rata annual leave and 10 or 12 sick days, a luxury impossible for a single parent.
Most importantly, both the nurse and the Centrelink worker have superannuation payments made by their employers, building future wealth, a benefit denied a single, jobless parent.
Charlotte Brewer, Shepparton

Devil in gas detail
We often hear that “Western Australia has long required its LNG exporters to reserve 15 per cent of their production for local use” (“Top industry chiefs, unions ‘are united’ to pass gas laws”, 16/11). Critically however, that 15per cent is calculated over a project’s lifetime.
West Australian LNG exporters are well behind on their obligations, supplying just over half of the required volumes by 2023. Woodside’s Pluto project, for example, has reportedly supplied less than four per cent of its gas production from its Pluto facility, well below the 15 per cent requirement.
AEMO actually forecasts domestic gas shortfalls in WA by 2028. Small additional amounts that would otherwise be exported on the spot market would avert these anticipated shortfalls.
The federal gas reservation scheme would complement, rather than duplicate, the actually ineffective WA version.
Lesley Walker, Northcote

Private school obsession
Your article on Xavier College (“This school’s black and red blazers are more than a uniform. They’re a passport to a prestigious network”, 16/11) was effectively a very large piece of advertising dressed up as news. What an outrageous puff-piece.
Furthermore, the obsession with private schools is at serious odds with our oft-touted Australian egalitarianism. The article dripped of superiority and the promotion of social advantage purchased with money.
Private schools, particularly the ‘elite’ ones like Xavier, are one of the main challenges to ‘social cohesion’ in contemporary Australia.
Simon Cox, McKinnon

Enigma cracked
It is time to revisit, once again, Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C Clarke’s 1968 movie, 2001: A Space Odyssey.
The various ‘alien monoliths’, huge black rectangular objects that were found on Earth, near Jupiter and in the lunar crater Tycho, remained an enigmatic mystery. The last one found on the moon was the source of intense electromagnetic radiation.
So, what were they? No doubt about it – they were data centres! Kubrick and Clarke’s movie ranks high on the list of all-time greats. Unfortunately, with each passing year, the movie’s visionary prescience becomes even more acute.
James Reiss, Abbotsford

Limits of a diagnosis
Well done, Heidi Everett for your courage in telling your story and your struggle with your diagnosis of schizophrenia. (″⁣I am a person with schizophrenia. I am not just a headline″⁣, 16/11.)
Society tends to blame people who have been diagnosed with a mental illness, which often comes from fear and lack of understanding, and sometimes leads to brutal social abuses. In a cruel way, it suggests that mental health is a social burden.
Hopefully, we can begin to have dignified conversations about mental health and be more inclusive as a society.
Julie Ottobre, Brunswick East

Person first approach
Hooray, for the wonderful article by Heidi Everett, who details livingwith her diagnosis of schizophrenia. It does not define her. It is a diagnosis of a condition that she has managed since the age of 23.
When I worked as a psychiatric nurse, that is how we spoke with and about our patients. First and foremost, they are a person. The relevant diagnosis is only part of that person.
Maree Williams, Kew

Tampering questions
I am a big fan of the current captain and I would like to believe Pat Cummins that only the three culprits knew of the ball tampering, but this case would have to be one of the few cases in international cricket in which no bowler was found guilty; only batters.
The other striking inconsistencies are that the ball in question was in the hands of the bowlers. How did they not see that it had been tampered? Surely, they saw itfor themselves and did not report it.
Finally, what is the point of ball tampering if the bowler does not use the reverse swing? It has to be done with their knowledge or there is no advantage.
Luke Mills, Richmond

In the rough of it
Australia was silly enough to get caught using sandpaper. It is not beyond comprehension that other countries also scuff the rough side of the ball using a variety of techniques, including bottle tops, but are more clever in doing so.
The idea is that one side of the ball is roughened and the other is smooth so the ball swings in the air. Now, here’s the thing that bothers me. It’s against the rules of cricket to touch the rougher side of the ball. But the smoother side of the ball can have sweat applied, and can be vigorously rubbed against clothing to shine the surface. Is this not also ball tampering?
Geoff Goonan, Glen Iris

Foo Fighters’ form
Sadly, I have to disagree with your reviewer regarding the Foo Fighters concert (″⁣Sweary and charming: Foo Fighters put on one hell of a show″⁣, 16/11). I adore the FF’s music and this is the second concert of theirs I have been to.
On both occasions, the music was so loud it was distorted to the point where you sometimes couldn’t make out the lyrics or the melody and it took several lines before you worked out which song was being played.
Do they need a better sound engineer? Maybe ask AC/DC for some advice. They can do loud and sweary brilliantly.
Kerry Bail, Beaconsfield Upper

AND ANOTHER THING

Matt Golding

Cricket
Seems we have another innings of ″⁣sandpapergate″⁣. Looks like they’re batting on a sticky wicket.
Mike Wilton, Safety Beach

I’ve lost so much respect for the Australian cricket team over the “sandpaper” incident. I’ve also lost all respect for Pat Cummins. This is a new low by Cricket Australia.
Leoni Mather, Melbourne

Some might call Cricket Australia’s ongoing sandpaper-gate shemozzle a classic case of “my truth” versus “your truth” versus “his truth”. Others might take a view, more akin to Sir Walter Scott’s, ″⁣Oh, what a tangled web we weave, when first we practise to deceive!“
Deborah Morrison, Malvern East

Maybe AI could do a quick audit of integrity in politics, business and sport? We could do with some signposts just now.
Glenda Johnston, Queenscliff

Homelessness, cost of living, wars, climate emergency: none of this matters when there are conflicting accounts of who knew what in a cricket game eight years ago. Move on.
Louise Kloot, Doncaster

Give every bowler a piece of sandpaper, so we can all go back to ignoring cricket.
Anthony Barnes, Kinglake

Furthermore
What does the billionaire want out of the Victorian election? What is it that’s said about ‘no free lunches’?
Michael McKenna, Warragul

If the super-wealthy can afford large donations to political parties, they can afford higher tax rates. Or maybe all political donations over, say, $1000 could be taxed?
John Pinniger, Fairfield

In Melbourne, seemingly″⁣bread and circuses″⁣ stand for yet more eateries in a railway station. (″⁣Why the Melburnian of the Year wants to bulldoze the city’s most famous building″⁣, 15/11).
Bernd Rieve, Brighton

It is clear from Tim Wilson’s call for federal Labor to repeal property tax changes that he represents investors and the owners of capital, rather than first home buyers.
Peter Baddeley, Portland

The opinion newsletter is a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own. Sign up here.

From our partners

Source: The Age

At a glance

Topic
Health
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira