As a retired solicitor, I applied my litigation experience to carefully read Cam Bancroft’s account of Sandpapergate, published in the Herald yesterday (“Alone, betrayed: time to tell the truth”, November 20). I then sought to recall Pat Cummins’ words at his press conference on Friday 13. Many commentators have stated the two versions can’t stand together, but in my opinion, that’s not the case. In his version, Cam speaks of players and coaches walking in and out of the change rooms while the sandpaper strategy was being discussed and of various persons offering their views. But nowhere does Cam state specifically who said what, other than to make it clear that Dave Warner was a strong advocate of using sandpaper, while Steve Smith and Kate Hutchison wanted nothing to do with such a strategy. Nowhere does Cam specify what was the actual participation of any of the bowlers in those discussions. It’s therefore possible that some players agreed that heavy work on the ball was required, and it’s also possible that some players did not know that sandpaper was to be used. Cam also states that he asked the bowlers whether his work was effective in causing the ball to swing, but he does not say that he specifically asked whether his sandpapering work was being effective. For his part, at his press conference, Pat was very specific in stating that he did not know that sandpaper was being used or that sandpapering had been agreed as a master plan. That statement, while possibly suspicious in its carefully chosen specificity, can stand together with Cam’s version. Danny Sankey, North Willoughby
Mitchell Starc said he stood by a joint statement released in 2021 with fellow bowlers Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon denying they had “any knowledge that sandpaper had been taken onto the field in Cape Town to tamper with the ball” (” ‘Angry, betrayed and alone’: Who knew what in the Sandpapergate saga”, smh.com.au, November 20). Fair enough – but that’s not the same as saying that they had no knowledge about sandpaper possibly being used to tamper with the ball. Are they being economical with the truth? Or just very careful with their words? David Gordon, Cranebrook
I fully support Pat Cummins, until such time as Cricket Australia conducts a forensic investigation and interviews the entire travelling party to South Africa (“Backs against the wall”, November 20). The term “everybody knew” has been used too broadly. The Australian captain should be offered more support in the short term, the forum will not succeed in uncovering those who knew, those who genuinely did not know, and those who were aware but preferred to stay silent. David Goldstein, Balgowlah
Kate Hutchison’s words are telling in the sorry Sandpapergate saga (“Team staffer who spoke up against use of sandpaper”, November 20). “That being part of the team did not mean having to accept everything the team was doing.” And she didn’t. Shame on the rest of them. Vicky Marquis, North Sydney
Culprit needs to be fingered
In my teaching past, I witnessed a principal interviewing three students who were caught truanting from school. The principal’s main interest was to determine which student made the first suggestion to leave the school premises. In a similar vein, I feel it is important to put the Sandpapergate to rest by finding the culprit who first suggested using the sandpaper, and secondly determining who was sent out to procure said sandpaper. We surely can’t consider the whole team to be condemned for the actions of a few. Eric Sekula, Turramurra
The cricket sandpaper saga rolls on. I was recently looking at the famous 1905 photograph by George Beldam of Victor Trumper jumping out to drive. He has a small cap perched on his head, he does not seem to be wearing batting gloves and has flimsy pads. His bat looks like a matchstick. Compare the current batsman with helmet covering head and face, heavily padded batting gloves and pads, arm guards and a massive lump of willow. Things have improved for the batsman, but for the bowler not much has changed. He (she) just has the ball. Is it therefore a surprise if the bowler tries to level the playing field? Alan Templeman, Wyoming
I’m going to forgive the Herald for the awful bon mots in the last paragraph of today’s editorial: “Cricket Australia must pad up” and then that their “reputation will be reduced to ashes” (“No winners as scandal shocks cricket lovers”, November 20). I forgive because I have a cricket-related bon mot of my own: the “cheating scandal” has been getting some Deep Extra Cover. Or is this scandal a Deep Extra Cover-up? Tim Egan, Mosman
Just supposing that the little square of sandpaper was suddenly uncovered, how much would it be worth on the market? Nedra Orme, North Sydney
Sweet and sour
In the 2005 Ashes series, English players used Murray Mints to doctor the ball to achieve reverse swing. The result: England won the series and numerous OBEs and MBEs were awarded to the coaches and players. Sunscreen and trouser zippers have also played a role in English cricket. Meanwhile, in Australia, a small piece of sandpaper was used on a past South African tour and eight years later we’re beating ourselves up about it, and if the commentators are to be believed, the fallout threatens the future of Australian cricket. I think a deep breath and some perspective are in order. Matthew Holle, Erskineville
The only way to eliminate this existential threat of Sandpapergate to the future of world cricket is to make the use of sandpaper mandatory. Neil Maclean, Bowral
Truth and ethics aside, how can vigorously employed cricketers drop a small sandpaper piece into their undies and expect it to stay put ’til needed? Is there a small drawer? Rosemary O’Brien, Ashfield
My wife complained bitterly this morning saying: “Why is the Herald so full of this rubbish about cricket? Who really cares?” I tried to explain that the issue had nothing to do with cricket. What the fuss was about was a question about the values and principles that support our society. Had we given up those long, dearly held beliefs in the importance of honesty, integrity and truth in favour of winning at all costs – not just on the sporting field but also in the much bigger and more important arenas of local, national and international governance? Were lying and cover-ups now accepted and honourable practices, so long as they helped us win not just in sport but in all the activities of society – work, politics and social relationships? Andrew Caro, Greenwich
As a follower of Test cricket for more than 75 years, I am heartbroken at the scandal erupting around us, which is being called Sandpapergate. Thankfully, whoever one believes, whatever the eventual outcome, there is one bright spark to lighten the gloom, and that is Boonie’s moustache. He was an entertaining batsman in his playing days, and now his fabulous facial adornment is providing a much-needed reason to smile in these sad days. Coral Button, North Epping
As one who has not the slightest interest in cricket, I am finding that I finish reading the Herald far sooner at the moment, so I am out in the garden before the late spring sun makes it too hot. Ron Brown, Wallsend
Hold three amigos to account
Lisa Visentin reports that the trio of Trump, Xi and Putin at their meeting in the Chinese city of Shenzhen have “cast themselves as peace brokers capable of ending wars, reining in the nuclear arms race, and securing global stability” (“‘We are really making history’: Trump, Xi and Putin issue ‘peace’ declaration after rare summit”, smh.com.au, November 20). However, their record in the past is well captured by a cynical interpretation of the motto from the 1986 movie Three Amigos, namely, “Wherever there is injustice, you will find us; wherever there is suffering, we will be there; wherever liberty is threatened, you will find … The Three Amigos!” Hence, Xi’s recommendation that nuclear weapons be “comprehensively prohibited and completely destroyed”, and Putin’s wish to end the conflict in Ukraine may well be met with scepticism. Nonetheless, they are now well publicised positions, behind which the rest of the world’s leaders should unite and seize the moment to urge action. Paul Casey, Callala Bay
All I could do is snort with disgust when I read about the declaration of peace by three of the least peaceful men in the world. Surely peace is not living with bombs, drones and fear. Two have started wars that are continuing despite their egotistical ideas that they would be over in a very short time, and the third is controlling populations with fear, violence, prisons and even death. And yet here they are preaching peace to the world. I, for one, cannot believe them. One is a clear dictator, another pretends to run a democracy but funnily enough he always wins, and the third has tried his best to flout the laws and democratic values of his own country. Their thirst for power and wealth defines them meeting to decide the fate of nations without those nations being included. They seem to think they are like the Gods from Greek mythology playing with the lives of men. The rest of the world dubbed The Coalition of the Willing must get stronger to counter this blatant grab for the world. Augusta Monro, Dural
Donald Trump is meeting with Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, southern China. Trump admires Xi Jinping. Trump’s right-hand man Elon Musk has established large-scale manufacturing of Teslas in China and customer reports are that the Teslas coming out of the factory in China have fewer fit-and-finish problems than those built in Texas. Perhaps the outcome of the current meeting will be Trump and Xi Jinping announcing that China will build the AUKUS submarines? It may be the only way they get built on time. Joseph Fernandez, Mosman
Words beat shirtfront
Remember when Tony Abbott was going to “shirtfront” Putin? Not much came of that. All talk as usual. And here’s our shrinking violet of a PM fronting the Russian leader with this, “And I say very directly to president Putin: end your war, end it now” (“Albanese stares down Putin at APEC summit”, November 20). Well, who is the real statesman? Peter Hayes, Port Macquarie
I don’t really know much about Vladimir Putin, but I suspect he’s not going to be overly concerned about cold looks and lecturing from Anthony Albanese. If, on the other hand, we were to stop buying petroleum products produced from Russian oil, he would feel it where it hurts. Time for Australia to stop empty posturing and actually do something. John Croker, Woonona
Musk joins scurrying rats
It’s sickening but not unexpected that Elon Musk should be weaselling out of any responsibility for Trump and MAGA’s rise (“Musk rues election cash splash”, November 20). After all, like the tech billionaires and Republican members of the US Senate and Congress, money and power have always trumped values, decency and principles. Where were Musk’s principles when he threw millions, possibly billions, at MAGA’s campaign spending, exerted pro-Trump social media influence, made rally appearances in support of Trump and MAGA, and took significant leadership roles in Trump’s administration to enact MAGA doctrine and bring misery to millions and enrich himself? Beware the money- and power-obsessed, for their values relate only to themselves and the poor saps who believe in these “champions” are the hoodwinked. The rats are also scurrying here in Australia as Pauline Hanson and One Nation scrub all mention of Trump hero-worship from their websites. So be very cautious of all those trumpeting Australia’s billionaire-backed Trump. Alison Stewart, Riverview
Sky-high cost of new-builds
The least featured situation in the discussion of loss of available housing is the affordability of what is being built and the associated cost (“Upmarket apartments foil Minns’ housing plan”, November 20). North Sydney is awash in high rise and “state significant development” projects. But there are three critical deficiencies. First, the plethora of units under construction, and approved or soon to be, are marketed as luxury apartments. Ironically, the two-bedroom units are often marginally larger than one-bedroom units in earlier builds. Second, starting price. While it favours downsizers, it is unaffordable for many upsizers needing to sell current apartments. Finally, the actual number of affordable units. The program favours developers who can offer payment to receive concessions on height, floor ratios and a reduced number of lower priced units. An example is an 80-unit complex with 3 per cent affordable housing. Two or three units does not mirror the need, but certainly adds to profit. Immigration policies, AI short- and long-term impacts and life quality are all in play. The government needs to take a hard look at desirable density and social outcomes. Robert Caraian, Crows Nest
Threats before Lowy talk
I attended the Jerusalem Post conference at which Steven Lowy delivered a powerful opening address (“Business chief says anti-Jew hate must not be normalised”, November 20). To clarify, the venue was changed at the eleventh hour to a secret location because of death threats, and hence the need for heavily armed police guards. Moreover, for safety reasons, we were advised to remove our conference lanyards when leaving the venue to avoid being harassed by protesters who had arrived later in the day. This is an example of the type of hate and intolerance that Mr Lowy described and which must not be normalised. Liza Rybak, Bellevue Hill
Criticism of Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians through continued bombing, killing, illegal land acquisition and human rights deprivation is not antisemitism. They are facts that people have a right to have an opinion on and these opinions don’t stem from a racial point of view, rather from a detestation of what appears to be the destructive mindset of the Israeli government. I too, Mr Lowy, would like Israel to continue to exist, but with Palestinians as free and rightful citizens of the country as well. I think most people want Israelis and Palestinians to coexist. It is not antisemitic to wish for peace. Claudia Drevikovsky, Croydon
Coalition creates monster
Waleed Aly writes that the Coalition’s crushing defeat in 2025 changed it from being in opposition to “being unviable” (“State of angst: Labor losing battle for Victoria”, November 20). Unfortunately for conservative voters, and despite the two “divorces” and reconciliations the Liberals and Nationals have had since then, they have still not learnt the lessons from their electoral spanking. Taylor and Canavan deride the Labor government at every opportunity, offering disdain but no viable policies beyond a revolving chocolate wheel of changing thought bubbles with no substance. They have also sought to fight One Nation from taking its far-right voters, criticising it in public, but giving it credibility where it counts, by preferencing it in the Farrer byelection and again in the Victorian state election. If One Nation wins seats in Victoria, it will largely be due to Coalition preferences, and they will have no one but themselves to blame for creating the monster that could bring about their political extinction. Alan Marel, North Curl Curl
Out of place in her party
In Rob Harris’ wonderful obituary for the independently minded Sharman Stone (“Stone defied PMs and party lines, and in death she stayed true to her convictions”, November 20) we are reminded that in her 20-year career (1996-2016) as a Liberal Party MP and Coalition minister she was “a woman who challenged conservative orthodoxy on abortion, championed contentious medical research and advocated for the right of terminally ill Australians to choose how they’d die”; that PM John Howard frequently disagreed with her; that she challenged Tony Abbott when as health minister he vetoed the RU486 abortion pill, and called him a liar over the Shepparton Cannery; campaigned to rid her party of its “blokey culture” by introducing quotas for women; campaigned for medical cannabis; and championed the settlement of Congolese refugees in her electorate. She was out of place in her party as it was during her time, and most certainly would be as it is today. John Payne, Kelso
- To submit a letter to the Sydney Morning Herald, email letters@smh.com.au. Click here for tips on how to submit letters.
- The Opinion newsletter is a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform. Sign up here.
Source: The Sydney Morning Herald
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇦🇺 AU
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira