A former Hobart teacher sued over allegations of repeated sexual abuse has had his appeal dismissed.
Earlier this year, Stephen Fane Noga, 76, was sued by one of his former Hobart Matriculation College students, now aged in her 60s, for allegedly sexually abusing her in the 1980s.
The woman also sued the State of Tasmania for failing in its duty of care.
Justice Stephen Estcourt found in favour of the terminally ill woman and awarded her a cumulative $1.6 million in damages.
The woman's solicitors said their client had been told she was expected to die from her condition within the next 12 months.
Solicitor Ellen FitzGerald said the appeal process had been stressful for her client.
"She's been trying to live out her last moments with her family, but this is obviously a huge burden to carry for anyone.
"She is just relieved and really pleased that the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal has heard her story, and she does feel closure because of that.
"Her bravery is pretty incredible," Ms FitzGerald said.
Ellen Fitzgerald says the appeal has been stressful for her client. (ABC News)
Noga 'correctly identified' potential apprehension of bias, judges find
In May, Mr Noga's legal team launched an appeal against Justice Estcourt's decision on four grounds.
The first was that social media posts, reposts and comments made by Justice Estcourt "before, during and after" the trial that were "generally supportive of victims of sexual abuse" resulted in a perception that Justice Estcourt would be more inclined to find in favour of the woman.
One of the social media posts shared by Stephen Estcourt that was included in the appeal. (Supplied)
The three other grounds alleged that he "erred in law", including by criticising Mr Noga's evidence and accepting the plaintiff's, which they argued was "glaringly improbable".
In the reasons for dismissing the appeal, the Full Court, comprised of Justice Robert Pearce, Justice Tamara Jago and Acting Justice Paul Slattery, said Justice Estcourt did not make any of the factual errors alleged by Mr Noga.
Regarding the social media posts, they said Mr Noga "correctly identified circumstances which gave rise to an apprehension of bias".
The court found that while "sympathy for victims is proper and universal", the nature, number and timing of the posts gave rise to reasonable apprehension of bias.
One of the social media posts shared by Stephen Estcourt that was included in the appeal. (Supplied)
The decision described 13 social media reposts made by Justice Estcourt between February 1 and March 21 this year.
"The hypothetical observer had reason to believe that the posts, because of when they were made in the context of the trial, might have something to do with the case," the decision reads.
While the posts indicated a potential apprehension of bias, the court decided Mr Noga waived his right to raise an objection in his appeal, due to his failing to make an objection during the trial.
They found Mr Noga and his legal team were "sufficiently aware" of circumstances that would justify an objection during the trial.
"Had the matter been raised, the trial judge would have had the opportunity to advise whether the posts were made by him, to disclose any other posts of a comparable nature and to provide any relevant explanation or information," the decision states.
Following the decision, the woman's barrister, Bruce McTaggart, KC, asked for orders that Mr Noga and the state pay his client's legal costs for the appeal.
This was opposed by the state.
A further hearing regarding costs will be held on Thursday.
Source: ABC Australia · Sophie Jaggers
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇦🇺 AU
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira