Chequered tablecloths. Crusty garlic bread. Hand-rolled gnocchi. Why generations of customers keep returning to this Inner West institution (PLUS: three more old-school Italian restaurants to try).

November 22, 2026

Filicudi

Italian$$

Let’s forget about the shiny new restaurants for a moment, and take a step back in time – back to the places where garlic bread is served in plastic wicker baskets, gnocchi is wonderfully misshapen, and every main includes a side.

These are the old-school Italian restaurants, like Filicudi in Five Dock, that held onto their chequered tablecloths as the world changed around them. No QR codes or AI-generated menus here, just specials scrawled on a chalkboard and a woman with a melodic Italian accent who won’t clear your plate until it’s empty.

Filicudi is a time capsule of Italian charm, with faded photomurals of country landscapes, a brown-brick service window, and dozens of empty chianti fiasco bottles strung from a wooden pergola ceiling. One above our table has a message, written on raffia with permanent ink, recalling a birthday celebrated here more than 30 years ago. Tonight, another birthday is being marked by diners clinking their glasses of BYO red wine (corkage $4.50) at the streetfront table. So it goes.

Those chianti bottles have been a core part of the restaurant’s identity since it opened in 1979, surviving four changes in ownership, says Debbie Colacicco. She bought the business from head chef Maria Carbone in 2024, in partnership with Gilbert Colacicco, Anabela Falato and Robert Falato. Carbone still runs the kitchen, alongside co-head chef Aasish Parajuli.

“The original owners wanted to recreate the atmosphere of the vineyards back home in Italy,” she says.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

“Many Italian migrants naturally turned to hospitality because it was something they knew, loved and were good at. They helped introduce Australians to the wonderful regional cuisines of Italy and shaped so much of the food culture we enjoy today.”

Former owner Elio Frauemeni (right) and Gennaro Migliori in 1992.michele mossop

The restaurant was founded by two brothers from the Sicilian island of Filicudi, Colacicco says. She doesn’t know their names. They sold the restaurant in 1989 to restaurateur Elio Fraumeni, who ran it for 25 years. Nowadays, Fraumeni is at Rosso Italian in Gladesville. He does know the brothers’ names, but declines to tell me.

I suppose that’s a rabbit hole for another time.

In the meantime, let me tell you about the food. The menu reads like a greatest hits of Italian cuisine: spaghetti bolognese, lasagne, calamari fritti. Entrees and pasta dishes are available in small and large sizes, but even the small would be considered large at newer establishments. Hand-rolled gnocchi is the specialty, made on site each morning.

Service is fast. A Campari soda arrives within minutes, served in a glass tumbler with ice and a wedge of orange. The garlic bread follows soon after, two halves of a crunchy white bread roll, butter-yellow and a little burnt on the edges. Nostalgic. Then, the calamari – soft beneath pale batter, scattered with parsley.

The gnocchi ragu is exceptional. The perfect texture – just soft enough to create that melt-in-the-mouth feeling, with just enough bite to hold its shape. The sauce is unabashedly big on flavour, rustic with long-cooked beef and tomato, the small size so generous it pushes us into a food coma for the remainder of the evening. I can’t remember the last time a dish came so close to emulating my nonna’s gnocchi. It takes me back to being a kid.

The gnocchi ragu, showered with crumbled parmesan.George Chan

The rocket salad arrives so heavy with sheets of freshly shaved parmesan you can barely see the leaves for the cheese. As it should be. The dressing is light, the white balsamic a welcome counterpoint to the pollo saltimbocca – two flattened chicken breasts, each topped with a thicker-than-expected slice of pancetta, bathed in tomato sugo and molten mozzarella. They’re accompanied by a simple side of steamed vegetables.

There’s a faded newspaper article, framed on a shelf. “Sydney’s best pizza”, it reads. Back then, Filicudi’s pizza would have seemed ahead of its time – wood-fired with high-hydration dough, freckled with spots of char, with toppings like fresh burrata and basil. It holds up.

Filicudi may have passed through many hands over the years, but its warmth, character and home-style Italian cuisine remain unchanged. So, too, does its clientele – regulars who return for midweek meals and milestones, generation after generation, as the ultimate testimony to the strength of this inner-west institution.

Three more to try: Old-school Italian in the Inner West

Da Franco

Nearly every day, for 35 years, Franco Graniero has opened his Parramatta Road restaurant. On the day we visit, he opens just for us – lone diners on a Monday afternoon, watching traffic pass by. The dining room is full of character: a tiny bar with Vespas on the roof; a faded surrealist painting hung alongside maps and Italian flags; and an old piano on standby, for when the house-made limoncello hits (BYO wine available, $2.50 corkage). Visit on Wednesday night for seafood – Graniero is known for his spaghetti marinara. He also makes a mean garlic bread, the kind with parsley and fresh garlic cloves smeared on crusty white bread.

137 Parramatta Road, Concord, (02) 9747 4700

Pan Roma

Pan Roma feels like Little Italy in its heyday. The restaurant has been around since 1973, and, on a Friday night, the dining room is booked and busy with birthdays, catch-ups and the occasional solo diner. It’s BYO ($2 corkage per person), but the handwritten wine list features imported bottles of chianti, sangiovese and nero d’avola ranging in price from $37 to $55. Order the saltimbocca alla Romana if it’s available, and hope it’s one of those nights when the ricotta cheesecake has just come out of the oven.

397 Parramatta Road, Leichhardt, (02) 9560 5874

La Botte D’Oro

Don’t let the modern facade fool you: La Botte D’oro has been part of Leichhardt’s Little Italy since 1977. It’s the one to visit for pizza – remarkably good, even when ordered for takeaway. It features a well-risen crust, grazed by the wood-fire, with a light chew; and toppings that feel like faithful riffs on the traditional favourites  You can also pop in for your morning espresso, picking up a fresh-baked and flaky sfogliatella riccia or chocolate krapfen (Austrian-style doughnut) for just $5 a piece.

137 Marion Street, Leichhardt, labottedoro.com.au

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

From our partners

Source: The Age · Bianca Hrovat

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira