After Marijana Rudan moved house from the inner west to Sydney’s north shore, she noticed conversations often started in one very direct way.

“The first question anyone asks you is ‘What private school are we putting kids down for’?” Rudan said.

Unsure of how to respond at first, Rudan began doing some research, quickly realising it might be too late for her kindergarten-aged daughter Madeleine to secure a year 7 place at a local independent school. “I was anxiety ridden because my daughter was 5, and I hadn’t put her down for any.”

The family was offered a year 7 spot at Wenona at the last minute.
The family was offered a year 7 spot at Wenona at the last minute.

Drawn to its highly regarded principal Dr Briony Scott, Rudan put her daughter down on the waitlist at Wenona in North Sydney. By year 6, Wenona had not called, and Rudan accepted a place at another private school.

“Then, we get a phone call from Wenona, saying ‘We’ve got a place’,” she said. They dumped the other school and paid the enrolment fee.

Two years later, they had absorbed sharp fee hikes and suddenly the school was an entirely different financial proposition. “We could afford it between the two of us. It was more [a question of] why? And is it worth it, based on what we could see?”

The plan was to switch to nearby Monte Sant’Angelo Mercy College, which was then about half the price of Wenona. But her daughter wanted them to consider Willoughby Girls High School, which Rudan thought was too much of a jump. She obliged her daughter by going on the school tour. The older students who led the tour were passionate, committed and proud of the school.“We just both walked out and we couldn’t fault it. We just couldn’t find any reason why we wouldn’t send her there.” So they enrolled.

The Rudan family’s move back to public education bucks a much bigger trend. Across the state and the country, thousands more families are shunning the public system in favour of private schools. In NSW, there are 70,000 more students last year in independent schools compared to 20 years ago and 35,000 more pupils in Catholic schools. Much of the non-government growth is in low-fee schools where tuition is less than $10,000 a year.

At the other end of the spectrum, Sydney’s high-fee schools have become a different financial proposition. Scots College in Bellevue Hill charged $13,772 for year 12 tuition in 2005. If fees had increased in line with inflation, it would cost $23,671 two decades later. But in reality, fees are already double that.

When choosing a school, parents can look for data points like NAPLAN results and facilities to get a sense of a school’s culture. If a parent chooses to judge a school on academic outcomes such as the HSC, Willoughby Girls outperforms at least a dozen high-fee schools in the Herald’s annual league table.

But often other parents’ views of choosing a public school go beyond objective measures, veering into social perceptions and school gate chatter.

Mosman High parent Ghislaine Vazquez moved from Mexico to Australia in part due to the reputation of Australia’s strong public school system. However, the private school panic started in the Sydney mother’s group before her son was born. “Everyone was just talking about Scots, Shore, Riverview, and Redlands … I started thinking the public system was not a good system for my kids.”

The pressure intensified when her son progressed through Mosman Public School as year 5 and 6 students began to decamp to private schools.

She found the single-sex nature of many private schools unappealing. The facilities were impressive, but coming from Mexico, she found the uniforms with hats and ties slightly over the top. “This is too serious for a kid of 10, 12, 13 years old. They are kids,” she said.

Ghislaine Vazquez with her son Sebastian, who attends Mosman High after going private for a couple of years.
Ghislaine Vazquez with her son Sebastian, who attends Mosman High after going private for a couple of years.Wolter Peeters

Her son, Sebastian, left public for private school for a period, but he wanted to return to Mosman High for year 7. Sebastian soon made friends and excelled in academics. The school facilitates trips to Balmoral and Manly to do extracurricular activities such as surfing. He is in year 9 and has been able to pursue his passion for football. “He has been able to do his sport at a very competitive level,” she said.

Mosman High parent Tamara Neal sent her children to Redlands for primary but when her son reached Year 6, also opted for Mosman High.

“Even when I was telling people my son had moved from Redlands to Mosman High, I suspected they were thinking: ‘Did you run out of money? Did you get divorced or did you get expelled’?”

Extracurricular programs spanning music, drama, and arts, as well as the teaching staff, have impressed her.

“I would say the level of teaching is at least equal, if not better in the public system,” Neal said, singling out Mosman’s English department for praise.

Chatswood High School principal Robin Chand says removing the financial burden of private school fees can help some parents in ways that will tremendously benefit a child’s life. “That is something that will ease the family unit, have social impacts, psychological benefits, and people can breathe,” he says.

When parents tour his school, he discusses the education on offer, as well as flow-on benefits to the family budget in an economy in which petrol costs $2.60 a litre and interest rates are high. “Why pay $30,000 a year when you can take your family to France look at the Louvre or whatever else – and get the best?”

As some economists declare the country is heading for a recession, Sydney’s insatiable appetite for private schooling might be showing signs of cooling.

Enrolment data has not been released for this year but at think tank The Centre for Independent Studies, federal opposition education spokesman Julian Leeser last week said principals had reported a drop-off from waiting lists.

“I’ve had school principals recently tell me that because of the state of the economy at the moment, and the state of the government’s economic management ... there are schools that are having large numbers of families drop off their waiting lists because they simply can’t afford to have a non-government choice.”

But choice also goes beyond school sectors.

For Randwick High School parent Katherine Hole, whose son started in year 7, the merger of two single-sex schools by the NSW government into a co-ed campus was a big factor behind their decision to choose the school. They toured other private options and noticed the difference in resources. But ultimately, Randwick was close to home, its two big grass ovals offered plenty of space and the academic and subject offering was excellent. “I look at friends at private school, they’re still paying extra for tutoring,” she said.

After years of mulling over the decision, she says parents need to figure out what is right for them. “It is important to take a step back and look at what’s important for your kid, what made the decision for us was community, the impact on travel and what was going to make for a better family life.”

Parents opting out of private schools for public education are bucking a broader trend.
Parents opting out of private schools for public education are bucking a broader trend.Edwina Pickles

Concord High School P and C president Amber Hooker had also glimpsed local private school facilities before she toured the public school when deciding where to send her children. “We went on a tour, and it was a little bit confronting, to be honest, to see the building, especially in comparison to what there is available at other places,” she said.

After enrolling, the campus was renovated to create a better learning environment, and she likes how transparent the school is with dealing with behaviour and other issues. There’s also a range of extracurricular activities, and her son has completed the Duke of Edinburgh Award.

“I think the thing we have noticed over the years is it’s actually the passion of the teacher who makes the difference to the students,” she noted, saying they were excellent at Concord High.

Back at Willoughby Girls, Rudan was not certain she had made the right decision. “I felt a lot of parental guilt initially,” she said.

The public school’s mismatched cupboards and dated cooking appliances were obviously not as slick as those at Wenona, but she said her daughter was able to see the schools were not altogether different.

“Mum, when you turn that knob on, guess what? The stove still works,” she remembers her daughter telling her. Now, she said Madeleine truly loves her school and the commitment and passion of her teachers. “It’s a constant topic of conversation,” she said.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

Source: The Age · Christopher Harris

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira