For much of the past 12 years, Victoria resembled a one-party state. Three straight election victories by Daniel Andrews cemented Labor in the seat of power on Spring Street, largely unchallenged by a Liberal Party far better at fighting itself.
The business world adapted accordingly. If a deal with the government needed to be done, or a decision swayed, corporate heavy-hitters turned to Labor comrades willing to help open doors, build relationships and get results.
Who you know is just about the most important skill in lobbying, which is why so many of the firms that have succeeded in this era have been unashamedly partisan in their staffing and strategy.
It is also why the probable election of a Liberal government next Saturday – and what the bookies think will be a Labor wipeout – would bring with it a profound change in how power and influence are wielded in Victoria.
Some lobbyists have been carefully preparing for the prospect of regime change; others seem less willing to face the writing on the wall.
In boardrooms and backrooms, the sector is abuzz with gossip over which lobby shops – and which large institutions reliant on their own government relations teams – stand to win or lose from the demise of the Labor Party in Victoria.
There are few who want to talk on the record for a story like this. Lobbying is a dark art, after all, a pursuit that takes place in the shadows, where old alliances, connections and relationships are leveraged for influence over political decision-making.
Over the course of more than 15 interviews with key players, mostly on the condition of anonymity for commercial and reputational reasons, what nevertheless emerges is a picture of frantic competition to be ready to deal with premier Jess Wilson’s united team – or be left out in the cold.
“Everyone talks up their political links when it suits them,” one lobbyist said.
“The Labor firms will struggle at a state level. The whole point around lobbying is relationships and trust, and if you have relationships and trust, they [the politicians] are more likely to take your call.
“It’s been a Labor state for 12 years, and Labor people have been rewarded heavily.”
To prepare for the possibility of a new regime, some lobbying firms have been repopulating with Liberal-linked operatives. In that process, however, they are also competing with the Liberal machine itself. A party source, speaking on the condition of anonymity to detail internal matters, confirmed quiet conversations were under way with potential staffers to fill the ranks of a new government so that they could hit the ground running.
“The land grab for now is Labor firms trying to hire Liberals, but there is not a huge amount of Liberal talent out there,” another senior lobbyist said. “The smart people have secured talent, lined up who they are going to hire, but want to let the election play out first before they announce.”
The challenge, of course, is that after three terms of Labor, Liberal talent is comparatively thin on the ground.
“All these [Labor] shops are hiring second-rate Liberals who haven’t been employed since Scott Morrison was PM,” the managing partner of a bipartisan lobbying group said. “I’ve seen so many shops set up as partisan and then try and transition for a change of government, and it never works. Governments see right through it.”
An industry source said that while lobbying shops were loading up on staff, the bigger question was how to influence Liberal MPs and ministers, compared with those in power now, and the “narrative” that needed to be developed.
“What resonates with the blue team doesn’t always resonate with the red team,” the source said. “They need to be able to make the approach in a different way.”
The model for engagement with government, some say, is also set to change.
“You have to distinguish between what I call above the line lobbying – outfits that are on the register and do it properly and above board – and those that operate under the radar, [who] say they are not lobbyists but just go around and talk to their mates,” one veteran operative said.
“Suddenly, they will have no access and their business is shot … For the firms that are partisan, the business model is feast or famine.”
The corporate powerbrokers who hire lobbyists are contemplating their next moves too.
“A huge number of clients will leave their current representatives,” one executive said.
“The way things were done with the Andrews-Allan governments – it was gain access by connection, walk in and do a deal.
“That’s not normal. It’s a strange way of doing things, and the new government won’t operate with that sort of hustle.”
The prospective change of government comes at a moment of uncertainty in how the shadowy industry operates.
Premier Ben Carroll’s recent move to toughen the powers of Victoria’s Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission means the watchdog now has a lower investigative threshold to look at non-criminal conduct. IBAC has always looked at “improper influence”, so these changes will be front of mind for lobbyists in how they interact with government on behalf of their clients.
However, as this masthead recently revealed, Labor had also drafted and then abandoned separate laws to crack down on lobbyists. It means the state’s next government will come to power operating with what experts say remain some of the weakest rules in the country to manage corruption and influence over government decision-making.
Assessing the winners and losers
One of the few lobbyists happy to speak on the record about the impending change in Victoria is Matthew Harris, the former state director of the Nationals who is now the chief executive of Barton Deakin.
The firm is the “evil twin” of Hawker Britton, the Labor-aligned shop led in Melbourne by partners and former Labor advisers Emma Webster and Andy Gargett. Both are owned by global giant WPP.
“Barton Deakin is Coalition-aligned, while Hawker Britton is Labor-aligned,” Harris says. “Together, the two firms offer clients a transparent, bipartisan model, with specialist teams bringing deep experience and understanding from both sides of politics.
“That model recognises that businesses need to engage constructively with governments of all political persuasions. Our value comes from understanding how governments and oppositions think, how policy is developed and how decisions actually get made.”
Harris says Barton Deakin is strengthening its Victorian team by hiring former Coalition staffers Scott Samson and Terry Barnes.
“Whatever the result in Victoria, Hawker Britton will continue to work with and grow its federal client base, drawing on its deep understanding of the federal Labor government, while Barton Deakin’s expanded Victorian team will be well placed to help clients navigate the political and policy environment in Victoria,” he says.
This structure means that while, on balance, group performance may not suffer, Hawker Britton staffers are likely to feel some pain as state-based clients drop away.
Cornerstone is another firm tipped to pick up clients should Wilson form government. Its advisory board includes former federal Liberal minister Craig Laundy, who is from Sydney but has been spending more time in Melbourne, also because his family is the new owner of what was Nine’s talkback radio network including 3AW.
“The Laundy family having right-leaning radio station 3AW – the Libs love that,” one of Cornerstone’s competitors said.
Firms that have deliberately curated a bipartisan team are also expected to weather a transition of power well.
The Civic Partnership has both Labor and Liberal-aligned staffers and plans to hire at least one more conservative operative. Its Labor executives include ex-state minister Luke Donnellan and party powerbroker Alan Griffin, alongside former state Liberal vice president Jason Aldworth and one-time Liberal candidate Asher Judah.
SECNewgate is also considered well placed with its line-up including Katherine Hornbuckle and Nick Maher, a former chief of staff for Liberal governments in Victoria and federally.
The Melbourne office of GRACosway – which describes itself as multipartisan – has beefed up its staff linked to the conservative side of politics by bringing in Dominic Raff, who worked for Brad Battin when he was the Liberal leader. Howard government adviser Richard King is managing director of the firm’s public affairs practice.
One lobbyist said the best-placed firms were also marketing their ability to deal with One Nation.
Pauline Hanson’s party is on track to secure at least eight seats in Victoria’s upper house, where the Coalition is unlikely to have a majority. That will make One Nation’s votes crucial for Wilson’s legislative agenda, although she will have the option of trying to work with Labor and the Greens on some policies.
This may mean shops will see benefits in keeping some Labor-aligned staff. Some were also considering picking up Labor operatives as they entered the job market to deal with the Albanese government, an industry source said.
At Banksia Strategic Partners, Baillieu-era minister Ryan Smith has been playing a more prominent role. They have also merged with SAS Group, while keeping their branding, which features Queensland LNP figures Larry Anthony and Malcolm Cole.
Global advisory group Teneo is building out its Australian outpost, with several high-profile recruits joining the Melbourne office under ex-GRACosway executive Ben Wilson, a former adviser to NSW Labor premier Morris Iemma. They include Nicholas Xerakias, a former policy adviser to Liberal trade minister Andrew Robb, as well as Andrew Cox, a former state director of the Liberal Party in Western Australia and deputy director in Victoria.
Global advisory giant Sodali is growing in Victoria too, hiring KPMG’s corporate affairs head James Copsey, a former adviser to ex-Liberal premier Denis Napthine.
Industry rivals point to the Kos Samaras-led Redbridge Group as among the firms that may find the new dawn confronting, although Samaras, a former Victorian Labor Party strategist, points out that about 90 per cent of its work is polling, and the balance is lobbying. His fellow director Tony Barry is also a veteran Liberal operative.
Still, the flavour, one competitor says, is in the business’s name. “It’s not called PurpleBridge,” they said.
Spring Street Advisory may also find a Wilson government challenging, according to several of its competitors. The firm is led by Labor man Ken McAlpine, who was a chief of staff and adviser during the Bracks and Brumby governments. When contacted by this masthead, McAlpine said: “Watch this space.”
None of the other firms commented when contacted by this masthead.
AFL leans into Labor-aligned staffers
As for Melbourne’s major corporates, a change of government presents both challenges and opportunities.
According to two Liberal figures, speaking on the condition of anonymity, it may be more a case of the former rather than the latter for the AFL. Chief executive Andrew Dillon’s corporate affairs boss is Sharon McCrohan, who has worked for Labor luminaries including Bill Shorten, Steve Bracks and Paul Keating.
The Liberal sources say her work for the CFMEU and its former state secretary John Setka – as well as her high-profile representation of former PwC boss and Carlton president Luke Sayers, a close friend of former premier Daniel Andrews – has not been lost on the prospective Wilson government.
“It’s going to be significant. There are 10 clubs in Victoria, you would want to hope there is a strategy in place [for a change in government],” one of them said.
Polls be damned, McCrohan has nevertheless moved to engage three more Labor-aligned staffers to assist the league in its dealings with government. They are James Newton, a former speechwriter for Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, along with the former head of media for South Australian Premier Peter Malinauskas, Adam Todd. Shannon Rees, who is a former staffer to Julia Gillard, has been hired as consultant.
An AFL source, who was not authorised to speak publicly, stressed that the “AFL is a national game, and not every state government is Labor”. The league, the source said, “worked productively with all of them … [it’s] not an issue”.
At Crown, where the issues associated with state regulation are myriad, Howard-era adviser Gemma Allman – the private equity-owned gaming empire’s chief government and public affairs officer – runs a bipartisan operation. It includes several former Andrews staffers, including Chris Reilly and Olivia Harris.
Sector stablemate Tabcorp, led by former AFL boss Gil McLachlan, takes a similar bipartisan track under now Melbourne-based Daniel Meers, a former senior adviser to Malcolm Turnbull. Also on the team are former Labor advisers Stephen Nugent and Michael de Bruyn.
Read more on the Victorian election:
- The polls: Labor is facing an election day wipeout
- Warren Pickering interview: Why Pauline Hanson’s man is smiling
- Exclusive: How a Liberal win will reshape your neighbourhood
- Waleed Aly: There are two theories for One Nation’s surge. We’re about to find out which one is true
- Chip Le Grand: This is what a Jess Wilson government will look like
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
Source: The Age · Christine Lacy, Kieran Rooney
At a glance
- Topic
- Politics
- Country
- 🇦🇺 AU
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira