More than two years after she was badly burnt while wearing a hoodie purchased via Temu, Daniella Jacobs-Herd is still traumatised by flame and smoke.

Burnt toast and birthday candles send the 10-year-old Hervey Bay girl into fits of rage.

"Half the day is spent trying to calm her down and explain that it's okay and safe," Daniella's mother, Hannah, said.

Woman with brown hair and purple top wearing shorts sitting next to a girl with brown hair and a brown top

Hannah Jacobs-Herd says her daughter Daniella is triggered by burnt toast and birthday candles. (ABC Wide Bay: James C Taylor)

Temu recalled the unicorn-themed hoodie for failing to meet mandatory safety standards, and Ms Jacobs-Herd sought compensation through a local Queensland legal firm.

But the online shopping platform said it was merely an intermediary and liability for product safety rested with its suppliers.

The Chinese supplier, Sunshine Towels, has not responded to the lawyer's repeated attempts to contact it since the July 2024 incident.

A screenshot of a product recall notice featuring long, brightly-coloured hoodies.

Temu recalled the hoodie for failing to meet mandatory safety standards more than four months after the incident. (Supplied: ACCC)

Last month, law firm Shine Lawyers told Ms Jacobs-Herd it was closing the case and advised her to engage an international lawyer.

Ms Jacobs-Herd lives on a disability support pension and said the legal fees were out of her reach.

"$15,000 for a 20-minute consult — I don't have that sort of money lying around," she said.

"I'm at a loss of what to do."

'Nothing more important than safety'

In 2010, when Australian consumer law was last updated, online shopping made up 6 per cent of total Australian retail sales.

That surged to 24 per cent by 2025, led by online marketplaces selling products made by overseas suppliers.

Australian consumer law requires suppliers of goods to comply with mandatory safety standards.

Retail app graph

Temu has become Australia's most-used retail marketplace app. (Supplied: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission)

In a complaint to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) in June, consumer advocate Choice said that left a regulatory gap for online marketplaces claiming to be intermediaries between the supplier and consumer.

The ACCC acknowledged the need for reform in its response to Choice, noting a July meeting of consumer affairs ministers had prioritised the introduction of a general safety provision — laws making the entire supply chain liable for the sale of unsafe products in Australia.

However, those ministers recently decided a general safety provision would not be part of a consultation process currently underway for Australian consumer law reform.

A man wearing glasses, a suit jacket and light-coloured business shirt looks into camera with a serious expression.

Allan Fels says a general safety provision should be introduced as soon as possible. (Four Corners: Rob Hill)

Allan Fels was the ACCC chair when a general safety provision was last considered in a 2019 review of Australian consumer law.

He said the Jacobs-Herd family's experience showed the provision should have been introduced at that time.

"Given the dangers of products like this, it was probably best if they had enacted the law in 2019," he said.

"But certainly now, in the light of experience, the law should be enacted as soon as possible."

The assistant minister responsible for Australian consumer law, Andrew Leigh, said the government's current focus was on improving processes for recalling unsafe products, and a general safety provision would be a reform option for 2027.

Calls for ACCC to take action

Luke Nottage is an expert in consumer product safety law at the University of Sydney.

He said there were protections already enshrined in law that meant the Jacobs-Herd family should not be forced to pay for their own international lawyer.

Australian consumer law empowers the ACCC to make compensation claims on behalf of consumers harmed by unsafe products.

Professor Luke Nottage stands next to a bicycle.

Luke Nottage says the ACCC has little-used powers that could help the Jacobs-Herd family. (ABC News: Andrew Whitington)

The ACCC has used those powers twice since they were introduced, most recently in 2004, in cases against Australian companies that paid compensation to consumers harmed by their products.

Professor Nottage said the ACCC had "very good in-house lawyers" who could take up the Jacobs-Herd case.

"It would send a strong message … that you can't sell unsafe products harming Australian consumers in the Australian market,"

he said.

"I don't see why the ACCC is not doing this."

Professor Fels said there was "a strong prima facie case" for representative action by the ACCC.

"I would have thought … there is quite a strong looking case for them taking action, or possibly a representative action if they had more cases of harm," he said.

An ACCC spokesperson said the regulator had sought numerous court orders to refund, replace or repair faulty products sold to consumers.

However, these orders did not include compensation for damages beyond the value of the product.

"We rarely become involved in individual disputes, including those aimed at seeking individual redress," the spokesperson said.

Source: ABC Australia · James C Taylor

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira