Editorial

November 19, 2026 — 4:39pm

Of all the words said and written about the cheating scandal that haunts the Australian men’s cricket team, five from batsman Cameron Bancroft may be the most damning: “It was the whole team.”

Bancroft, who admitted to applying sandpaper to the ball in two Test matches, has echoed Usman Khawaja’s account of the scandal and says he carried the burden of lying about how much the wider team and the coaches knew and encouraged the tampering. “I took the bullet for everybody, and it was my choice,” Bancroft said.

There is enough blame to go around, but most should be directed at Cricket Australia. The sport’s top body has abjectly failed to handle the scandal for nearly a decade, has failed the players and coaches, and its continued failure to accept the seriousness of the crisis has resulted in weeks of public fallout and recriminations that show no sign of abating.

Most of all, it has failed the Australian public, turning a team that once held an exalted position in the national psyche into an international embarrassment. Instead of handling the cheating properly in 2018, stopping the rot at the time and cleaning up the culture, the stench of cover-up lingers.

Before the fateful South Africa tour in 2018, Cricket Australia fostered the win-at-all-costs mentality that allowed ball tampering to fester. In Bancroft’s account, everyone in the dressing room knew what was happening. Only media manager Kate Hutchison objected, he said, dispelling the idea that no one knew in advance and had the chance to stop it.

Bancroft is not blameless, and not only for rubbing sandpaper on the ball and keeping the team’s secrets for years. He admitted to being deceptive when questioned by Cricket Australia during its original investigation, which could not have helped the body do its job properly.

Still, Bancroft is within his rights to feel he has been made a scapegoat, as if he was used and spat out of the national team while others were allowed to rehabilitate their careers and earn their fortunes. Steve Smith and David Warner were allowed redemption, while Bancroft was shunned despite piling on runs in first-class cricket. Had history turned out differently, had the mess been properly dealt with years ago, he might well be opening the batting for Australia today.

Cricket Australia chair David Boon and chief executive Todd Greenberg, who were not at the helm at the time, this week announced an “independent forum” for those involved in the 2018 team to discuss their memories. If it was an attempt to quell the public slanging match, it backfired.

To end the sense of cover-up and restore trust will require taking the matter out of Cricket Australia’s hands. The scandal needs a proper, independent investigation by an authoritative outsider, and the organisation should hold a major review to prevent any repeat of such cheating.

Cricket Australia must pad up and earn back trust the hard way. Failing that, Australian cricket’s reputation will be reduced to ashes.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

From our partners

Source: The Sydney Morning Herald · The Herald's View

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira